Silver Commemoratives 144 Piece Mintmark & Variety Set, Circulation Strikes (1892-1954) All-Time Finest List

Number of
Required Items
144
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
69.236
Set Composition
Start This Set

The 144-piece silver commemorative set includes all of the 50 different type coin commemoratives issued from 1892 through 1954, plus each date and mintmark of the multiple issues. For instance, there was only one York commemorative issued, but there were three Cincinnati commemoratives (1936-P, 1936-D, and 1936-S) and 13 different Texas commemoratives. This popular series is filled with low-mintage coins, including the lowest mintage silver coins of the 20th century. Most commemoratives are mint state, as they are what is called NCLT, or non-circulating legal tender. Key issues of the series are the Hawaiian, Hudson, and Spanish Trail (low mintage type coins) and the Sesqui and Monroe (condition rarities), plus the Lafayette dollar among many others.

All-Time Finest (All Eras)

View PCGS Era
Rank Set Name % Complete GPA Weighted GPA with Top
Pop Bonuses		 Set Rating User
1 J & L 144 Complete Set 2016 2017 2018 HOF 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 100.00% 67.89 69.13 69.13
dodgers267
2 Rebel Yell Commemoratives 100.00% 67.58 68.08 68.08
Rawduck
3 Subway Tokens Silver Commemoratives 144 Set 2014 2015 2019 100.00% 67.43 R 67.86 67.86
psslomianyj
4 JFM57 98.61% 67.53 67.93 67.18
Fuljenz
5 JFS Collection 100.00% 66.99 R 67.04 67.04
GR
6 Bruce Scher HOF 2011 99.31% 67.20 R 67.36 66.99
tirebiz1
7 The Heller Collection HOF 2002 100.00% 66.80 R 66.81 66.81
Heller
8 D. L. Hansen 144 Silver Commeratives (1892-1954) 100.00% 66.77 R 66.80 66.80
DLH
9 Rush Family Collection 100.00% 66.74 66.74 66.74
MarkBRush
10 WPE Collection 2007 2008 2009 2010 100.00% 66.70 R 66.73 66.73
thessers
11 Terry's Toners 100.00% 66.64 R 66.67 66.67
U A Hogs 1960
12 Cali Collection 2003 2004 2005 2006 100.00% 66.66 R 66.66 66.66
MDCRB
13 Jewell Collection 100.00% 66.58 R 66.58 66.58
rcj2543
14 The Waverly Collection 100.00% 66.52 R 66.52 66.52
mcwik
15 Larry Shepherd 100.00% 66.48 R 66.51 66.51
Larry Shepherd
16 Raider Man Complete 144 Commemorative Set 100.00% 66.34 66.35 66.35
[email protected]
17 Gertzi Collection 99.31% 66.50 66.50 66.32
sagager
18 PROUD LEGACY Collection 100.00% 66.20 R 66.20 66.20
[email protected]
19 Rothenberger 100.00% 66.20 R 66.20 66.20
Rothenberger
20 Hidden Liberty Collection 97.92% 66.75 R 66.81 66.08
[email protected]
21 FBT Classic Silver Commems 100.00% 66.06 66.06 66.06
ftavennr
22 Driftwood Silver commemorative Set 100.00% 66.04 66.04 66.04
driftwood
23 WML Collection 100.00% 66.01 R 66.01 66.01
lepter
23 Ngok Li Collection 100.00% 66.01 66.01 66.01
Ngok
25 ScottSCollectio 100.00% 66.00 R 66.00 66.00
ScottSCollectio
26 PSC Classic Commemoratives 144 Piece 100.00% 65.95 R 65.95 65.95
Anonymous
27 psc 100.00% 65.95 R 65.95 65.95
psc
28 John Highfill 100.00% 65.84 R 65.84 65.84
John Highfill
29 BE Young 2012 2013 99.31% 66.81 R 66.83 65.73
beyoung
30 LV 98.61% 66.52 R 66.53 65.44
charles.jonath
31 Indian Bend Full Commem Set 100.00% 65.24 65.24 65.24
mcuttill
32 Colin 100.00% 65.22 R 65.22 65.22
[email protected]
33 CHO10-Commermorative Silver-144 100.00% 65.04 65.04 65.04
claudeh
34 JB3 Collection 99.31% 65.19 65.19 65.01
JEB3RD
35 Michael F. Hayes - Early Commemoratives 100.00% 64.98 R 64.98 64.98
mfhayes
36 Collector 100.00% 64.94 64.94 64.94
Collector
37 TEG Collection 100.00% 64.94 R 64.94 64.94
tgnagey
38 B. Yandell 99.31% 65.41 R 65.41 64.87
yandell
39 wespie 100.00% 64.87 64.87 64.87
[email protected]
40 lostmountainman 100.00% 64.56 64.56 64.56
lostmountainman
41 Sterling's Silver Commems 99.31% 64.79 R 64.79 64.25
Abbey
42 dgooch 100.00% 64.21 64.21 64.21
dgooch
43 Noble Coins 99.31% 65.25 65.25 63.99
mbenzmike
44 Louis Eliasberg 100.00% 63.92 R 63.92 63.92
45 Erudition Vintage Commemoratives 144-Piece Set UPDATED 99.31% 64.33 64.33 63.62
[email protected]
46 Chugum Collection of Classic Commemoratives 99.31% 64.02 R 64.02 63.49
DAVIDLAWRENCERC1
47 Kove's FirstGen Holder 144-piece Commem Set 97.22% 64.82 R 64.82 62.86
kurt_kovich
48 tms 97.22% 65.43 65.43 62.74
Tmselter
49 tenniswgc 95.83% 65.07 65.07 62.21
tenniswgc
50 Dewarsdt 98.61% 64.61 64.61 61.77
Dewarsdt
51 Steve's Silver 144 Piece Commemoratives 95.14% 65.00 65.00 61.42
footinsteve
52 gdenten 90.97% 65.85 R 65.85 61.33
gdenten
53 Major Tucker's Coin and Bullion 144 Piece Mintmark & Variety Set Circulation Strikes (1892-1954) 92.36% 65.55 65.55 61.23
[email protected]
54 Neisler early commems 97.92% 65.30 65.30 61.17
conserver
55 First Generation Holder Commems 94.44% 65.60 R 65.60 61.09
z20504
56 Nichols Family Collection 97.22% 64.75 R 64.75 60.66
Great_Lakes_Coin_Collector
57 weston collection 93.06% 65.39 R 65.39 58.02
dweston
58 goofydog 93.75% 64.91 64.91 57.60
goofydog
59 J&D Fishman Collection 90.97% 64.72 64.72 56.90
Jerry
60 Russell Collection 91.67% 65.21 65.21 56.25
surefoot
61 jimblasius 88.89% 65.42 65.42 55.00
Jim Blasius
62 TicketCollector UPDATED 85.42% 65.14 65.14 54.94
TicketCollector
63 Stony Point Collection 81.25% 64.10 64.10 53.36
Kliney
64 Lennonj 80.56% 66.44 66.45 52.94
Lennonj
65 Moxie 80.56% 66.13 66.13 49.78
pdionne
66 Stockman 70.14% 64.94 64.94 49.24
Redsheep
67 Old Glory Numismatics 144 Commemorative Set 53.47% 65.65 65.65 45.45
Lhicks101
68 Usedcatman UPDATED 65.28% 65.37 65.38 45.27
Usedcatman
69 Scabland Collection 67.36% 64.65 64.65 44.58
Scabland Collection
70 NanuNanu117 66.67% 65.69 65.69 43.13
NanuNanu117
71 Zin's Silver Commemoratives 144 Piece Mintmark & Variety Set 58.33% 64.98 64.98 43.02
mozins
72 Commemsurate Collection 66.67% 65.38 65.38 42.93
[email protected]
73 Connnecticut Collection 77.78% 65.74 65.74 41.72
cmboelhouwer
74 Jenny and Nick DiOrio Classic Silver Commemorative Collection 67.36% 63.57 63.57 41.39
JMB & NJD
75 The Full Chippewa Tribe 61.81% 66.56 66.56 40.78
rcraw6644
76 Fogbear's Complete Classic Silver Commemoratives 64.58% 64.86 64.86 37.78
fogbearsf
77 DSS Ag COMMEMS DMV 56.25% 65.54 65.54 37.63
dssheffield
78 Junge13 43.75% 65.35 65.35 35.91
tjunge13
79 Morgan575757 43.06% 65.86 65.86 35.10
spivey
80 [email protected] 51.39% 64.65 64.65 34.81
Anonymous
81 Plaza Mayor 50.00% 64.17 64.17 34.55
Plaza Mayor
82 SNJ Classic Silvers UPDATED 59.03% 66.90 66.96 33.66
pomianowski
83 Chesapeake Collection 43.06% 65.16 65.16 33.65
Chesapeake
84 Zach’s Commemorative Complete Set 56.25% 64.24 64.24 33.53
Anonymous
85 rjcent 43.75% 64.67 64.67 32.51
rjcent
86 Brewzer II 36.81% 67.13 67.26 32.34
Mike
87 Horgy19 51.39% 64.95 64.95 32.30
Horgy19
88 Bear Creek Collection 37.50% 65.77 65.77 32.16
BearCreek
89 Desert Rose 37.50% 67.25 67.40 32.03
Desert Rose
90 budmansarge 56.94% 58.84 58.84 32.01
budmansarge
91 tcmitssr 34.72% 65.93 65.93 31.15
Anonymous
92 Njrekdiver (2) 48.61% 64.94 64.94 30.69
Njrekdiver
93 LAZY OTTER 47.22% 64.32 64.32 30.57
LAZY OTTER
94 spikeinphilly - Silver Commemoratives Date/MM 38.19% 64.65 64.65 30.55
spikeinphilly
95 All_That_Glitters 37.50% 65.13 65.13 30.06
Anonymous
96 ac168 40.28% 64.91 64.91 29.96
ac168
97 SOlsonBFDL14 61.11% 65.54 65.54 29.89
SOlsonBFDL14
98 ss124 32.64% 66.18 66.18 28.91
[email protected]
99 bbayless3 51.39% 65.14 65.14 28.81
[email protected]
100 Ferreira Collection 32.64% 63.49 63.49 28.26
Ferreira Collection
101 CdA Collecting 44.44% 65.38 65.40 27.67
[email protected]
102 Caleb Clough's Collection 52.08% 64.88 64.88 27.45
Clough
103 [email protected] 45.14% 64.60 64.60 27.15
mollyzapper
104 rick's half dollars 44.44% 63.54 63.54 27.06
rick's half dollars
105 dgarris11 44.44% 64.72 64.72 26.49
dgarris11
106 SCB-Wisconsin 39.58% 63.96 63.96 25.83
ssccbb12
107 My Early Commems 47.92% 63.87 63.87 25.62
NotSure
108 Connecticoin 47.22% 65.31 65.31 25.48
Connecticoin
109 Marine's Oldest 39.58% 65.09 65.09 25.03
fryan1951
110 mcjacobs2000 37.50% 63.48 63.48 24.94
mcjacobs2000
111 hardin-omega 31.94% 64.78 64.78 24.91
hardin2413
112 b bergmann comm's 42.36% 64.34 64.34 24.39
bbergmann
113 The 55 Type Coin Set 29.17% 65.34 65.34 23.70
Grandson
114 jumpup88 40.28% 62.03 62.03 23.52
jumpup88
115 Commemorative Half Complete 144 Pieces 27.08% 65.36 65.36 21.73
Usclax31
116 Verum Americana 38.19% 65.69 65.69 21.48
Verum Americana
117 Jarhead Rick 35.42% 65.13 65.13 21.29
Anonymous
118 Benmosley (2) 31.25% 64.49 64.49 21.26
Benmosley
119 mgabba1 38.89% 59.36 59.36 19.90
mgabba1
120 JZF Classic Silver Commens 34.72% 65.72 65.72 19.68
JZF
121 Beal Enterprises 22.92% 63.92 63.92 19.67
Beal Enterprises
122 ironmanl63 27.78% 64.46 64.46 19.66
[email protected]
123 Steven’s classic commems 27.78% 63.28 63.28 19.30
Steven791
124 Kovach Collection 32.64% 65.23 65.23 18.64
fomoco
125 Alan E UPDATED 35.42% 60.31 60.31 17.56
AlanE
126 HChilds 29.86% 64.90 64.90 16.94
HChilds
127 Kdh1368 34.72% 64.43 64.43 16.82
Kdh1368
128 🇺🇸Silver•Comm’s🏔144.Mintmark & Variety set. (1892-1954). 29.86% 47.77 47.77 16.80
Ryan “RT” Thompson
129 DiggerD 30.56% 64.73 64.73 16.72
DiggerD
130 Rjrichards1 22.22% 63.72 63.72 16.28
Rjrichards1
131 The Bucky Collection 33.33% 65.21 65.21 16.12
wlabelle
132 Mailman28 26.39% 65.37 65.37 15.98
bthurm
133 walrus 144 Commem Set 26.39% 65.71 65.71 14.98
[email protected]
134 Commemoratives 12.50% 65.86 65.86 14.84
Street sweeper
135 Sam Martin 22.22% 65.28 65.28 14.53
sammis921
136 georgeatamian 14.58% 64.83 64.83 14.25
[email protected]
137 Tpmjr2004 UPDATED 29.17% 47.02 47.02 13.82
Tpmjr2004
138 Lion 20.14% 65.91 65.91 13.76
Anonymous
139 Arizona Silver 24.31% 65.10 65.10 13.05
tmor1
140 Matthew 23.61% 64.35 64.35 12.73
Matthew
141 jlzappin 15.28% 59.71 59.71 12.47
jlzappin
142 JKMulcahey 13.19% 62.60 62.60 12.21
JKMulcahey
143 Dick's Commemorative Silver 18.75% 64.75 64.75 11.92
littlestar280
144 Piffikk 20.83% 64.37 64.37 11.85
Piffikk
145 The MarcusJ Early Commemorative Set 15.28% 64.37 64.37 10.61
lionel99
146 U.S. Classic Commemoratives 18.75% 64.31 64.31 10.42
CollinsJ
147 pat4president1996 15.28% 52.15 52.15 10.17
pat4president1996
148 Mike 19.44% 55.87 55.87 09.52
Mike
149 bobdock 20.14% 65.27 65.27 09.32
bobdock
150 WC-Commemoratives 13.89% 63.45 63.45 09.06
wcaudill5331
151 occidental 20.83% 65.30 65.30 08.79
occidental
152 PHM 22.22% 66.00 66.00 08.70
PHM
153 Hawks7 14.58% 53.29 53.29 08.64
Hawks7
154 Ozarko Collection 18.06% 61.17 61.17 07.90
Ozarko Collection
155 stgecko 15.97% 65.30 65.30 07.89
stgecko
156 Nume Daengpairoch 8.33% 63.83 63.83 07.89
Numed
157 OTTO FLYNT - 3/25 L-2 14.58% 63.59 63.59 07.69
OttoFlynt
158 Hugh's Big Comm, Collection 12.50% 64.26 64.26 07.59
hrw1997
159 commemorative all varieties UPDATED 15.97% 59.96 59.96 07.58
Ttriple
160 bobvvv1 29.17% 39.17 39.17 07.43
bobvvv1
161 Vegas Strong #LiveLikeLisaP 15.97% 54.24 54.24 07.00
LivelikeLisaP VegasStrong
162 georgeatamian (2) 6.94% 64.95 64.95 06.96
[email protected]
163 Timmy31m 12.50% 44.55 44.55 06.00
Timmy31m
164 friedmad 12.50% 65.24 65.24 05.91
friedmad
165 Count718 13.19% 66.13 66.13 05.81
Count718
166 cboyera UPDATED 8.33% 52.68 52.68 05.79
cboyera
167 J.A. Benham Collection - Silver Commemoratives 144 Piece Mintmark & Variety Set - Circulation Strikes (1892 - 1954) 4.86% 63.70 63.70 04.02
J.A. Benham Collection
168 [email protected] 4.86% 65.65 65.65 03.61
Woodyfmod
169 klb1122 6.25% 64.25 64.25 03.53
klb1122
170 [email protected] UPDATED 4.17% 65.12 65.12 03.04
Anonymous
171 Hans Gruber 5.56% 64.47 64.47 02.66
Hans Gruber
172 CirculatedCommems 34.72% 5.23 5.23 02.40
CirculatedCommems
173 Duncaster Commemorative IV 2.78% 64.31 64.31 02.30
Duncaster
174 [email protected] 2.78% 65.44 65.44 01.62
Anonymous
175 RobertAgans NEW 1.39% 64.50 64.50 00.35
RobertAgans
176 [email protected] 0.69% 64.00 64.00 00.35
Anonymous
177 WENTWORTHCOLLECTION 0.69% 1.00 1.00 00.01
WENTWORTHCOLLECTION