Liberty Seated Dollars Basic Set, Circulation Strikes (1840-1873) All-Time Finest List

Number of
Required Items
44
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
66.480
Set Composition
Start This Set

This is one of the most challenging of all 19th century silver sets. The coins are big and heavy, leading to lots of bagmarks on most surviving mint state examples. In addition, rare dates abound, including the ultra-rare 1870-S, the tough Carson City issues, the rare dates in the early 1850s-the list could continue. Collectors usually choose to buy two examples of this series, one "No Motto" and one "With Motto." A complete set? A great joy and an even greater challenge!

All-Time Finest (All Eras)

View PCGS Era
Rank Set Name % Complete GPA Weighted GPA with Top
Pop Bonuses		 Set Rating User
1 D. L. Hansen Liberty Seated Dollars Basic Set, Circulation Strikes (1840-1873) 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 100.00% 64.77 R 66.29 66.29
DLH
2 Bruce Morelan Collection of Mint State Seated Liberty Dollars HOF 2004 2005 2006 2007 2015 2016 2017 97.73% 64.74 R 66.16 63.80
tradedollarnut
3 Louis Eliasberg 100.00% 60.71 R 60.79 60.79
4 American Girls 97.73% 63.52 63.82 60.56
SeatedCrazy
5 The Bel Air Collection 97.73% 62.96 R 63.04 59.82
OBrien
6 Arkansas Collection 97.73% 61.31 61.31 58.18
bluecreek
7 Fairfield Collection 97.73% 60.23 60.23 57.16
VanceOglesbee
8 Arizona Collection 2002 97.73% 56.02 R 56.02 53.16
MICHAELMAGDIC
9 Trader1873 93.18% 59.07 R 59.07 51.23
Trader1873
10 American Girls 2 79.55% 62.58 62.62 49.84
SeatedCrazy
11 The Linda Collection 93.18% 55.90 R 55.90 49.63
steveliu
12 rsh442 95.45% 54.19 54.19 49.21
Anonymous
13 Reel Coug Liberty Seated $ Basic Set 90.91% 53.23 53.23 43.72
Reel Coug
14 The Faith Marilyn Liberty Dollar Set UPDATED 79.55% 55.03 55.03 42.12
The Faith Marilyn Collection
15 Old Chelsea Collection 93.18% 45.38 R 45.38 41.91
friedfrank11
16 Prufrock322 79.55% 56.67 56.67 41.06
Prufrock322
17 DBBFDMMPRAJM 93.18% 44.12 44.12 38.05
Pickwickjr
18 J B N 81.82% 47.91 47.91 35.45
JBN
19 kingramii (2) 86.36% 45.28 45.28 34.66
[email protected]
20 Dan's Seated Dollars 79.55% 47.45 47.45 34.38
barberman1955
21 derf21 90.91% 41.49 41.49 34.08
derf21
22 kotto 79.55% 39.92 39.92 27.70
[email protected]
23 seated dollars 70.45% 40.50 40.50 25.42
Kent Bergene
24 TGM 84.09% 32.72 32.72 24.04
TGM
25 [email protected] 54.55% 46.95 46.95 22.76
Anonymous
26 Talkdoctor 61.36% 44.74 44.74 22.37
Talkdoctor
27 NewThugCity 75.00% 31.70 31.70 21.67
NewThugCity
28 camera28 31.82% 54.77 54.77 20.40
camera28
29 Southcounty Collection 63.64% 41.43 41.43 20.08
trymenc
30 Crawford Collection 36.36% 46.54 46.54 18.05
Anonymous
31 RIQ Memorial Set 31.82% 51.47 51.47 16.81
RIQ
32 The ABC Collection 25.00% 51.08 51.08 15.64
louis123
33 Quiver Collection 38.64% 53.61 53.61 13.40
Quiver Collectibles
34 D&D Seated $1 22.73% 59.19 59.29 12.70
Srotag
35 Blaylock 59.09% 23.64 23.64 12.30
Blaylock
36 Pazio’s Liberty Seated Dollar Collection 34.09% 41.49 41.49 12.07
Pazio
37 Piney Woods Collection 36.36% 38.44 38.44 10.20
Piney Woods Collection
38 Fernando Baez Guerrero 25.00% 51.38 51.38 09.70
fernandobaez
39 roblaw67 22.73% 34.59 34.59 07.23
roblaw67
40 RGS III 13.64% 62.57 62.57 06.70
RGS III
41 sellhart53 29.55% 22.40 22.40 06.52
sellhart53
42 jkharber 13.64% 37.30 37.30 05.71
[email protected]
43 long3218 22.73% 33.79 33.79 05.00
long3218
44 rsh442 (2) 18.18% 57.25 57.25 04.67
Anonymous
45 Issaquah Collection 11.36% 62.50 62.50 04.46
cdc-ecc
46 LA liberty seated dollar circ 22.73% 25.72 25.72 04.20
mccronecpa
47 Holy City 4.55% 41.54 41.54 02.76
P R S
48 Stuart's Seated Liberty Dollars 11.36% 55.56 55.56 02.55
StuGold
49 jjt2821 9.09% 17.47 17.47 01.69
[email protected]
50 Impossible Seated Dollars 9.09% 18.88 18.88 01.54
Vincent Sims
51 Jake’s collection 4.55% 48.67 48.67 01.49
Jake’s collection
52 J. R. Robinson Collection 9.09% 33.75 33.75 01.38
J.R.Robinson
53 Kraken Seated Liberty Dollars 4.55% 64.50 64.50 00.66
Kraken
54 DavidSpence 4.55% 1.00 1.00 00.05
DavidSpence