American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof (2006-present) All-Time Finest List

Number of
Required Items

Current Finest
Possible Set Rating

71.000

Beginning in 2006, the U.S. Mint began issuing $50 gold coins. These are the first .9999 fine 24-karat gold coins ever struck by the mint. Considered legal tender, the content and purity is guaranteed by the United States government.

All-Time Finest (All Eras)

Rank	Set Name	% Complete	GPA Weighted	GPA with Top Pop Bonuses	Set Rating	User
1	Goldminers 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	R 71.00	71.00	Goldminers
1	ikes777 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	R 71.00	71.00	ikes777
1	STK 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	R 71.00	71.00	STK
1	aerovac12 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	R 71.00	71.00	[email protected]
1	erdocjcm 2017 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	R 71.00	71.00	[email protected]
1	V.M. Buffalo Proof 1oz. Gold Collection 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	R 71.00	71.00	V.M. Collection
1	gjgott 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 10 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	71.00	71.00	gjgott
1	ErasmusHall 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	71.00	71.00	ErasmusHall
1	QT921700 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 10 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	71.00	71.00	QT921700
1	JP 2022 2023 2024 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	71.00	71.00	JP
1	ProofCollection's Gold Buffalo $50 Proof Set 2023 2024	100.00%	70.00	71.00	71.00	ProofCollection
12	KM Vennekotter Collection 2008 2009 2010 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 UPDATED	100.00%	70.00	R 70.94	70.94	Vennekotter
13	tmtexxonmobil UPDATED	100.00%	69.86	70.73	70.73	[email protected]
14	Kjoconnell UPDATED	100.00%	69.82	70.64	70.64	[email protected]
15	bbarnes72 American Buffalo UPDATED	100.00%	69.77	70.55	70.55	bbarnes72
16	The EFG Collection 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 10 2024 UPDATED	95.24%	70.00	71.00	67.77	eguckes
16	ritzfam 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 UPDATED	95.24%	70.00	71.00	67.77	ritzfam
16	2sommer 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 UPDATED	95.24%	70.00	71.00	67.77	2sommer
19	D. L. Hansen American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof (2006-present) 2017 2018 2019 2022 UPDATED	95.00%	70.00	R 71.00	67.62	DLH
20	HawkeEye 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2019 2020 2021 2022 10 2023 2024 UPDATED	90.48%	70.00	71.00	64.55	HawkeEye
20	ElHajj1 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2017 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 UPDATED	90.48%	70.00	71.00	64.55	ELHAJJ1
20	The Diehl Gold American Buffalo $50 Collection 2024 UPDATED	90.48%	70.00	71.00	64.55	Roger Diehl
20	My Buddy Collection 2023 2024 UPDATED	90.48%	70.00	71.00	64.55	7over8
20	KelJess Gold Buffalo Set UPDATED	90.48%	70.00	71.00	64.55	BS91367
25	Terry & Nicole UPDATED	90.48%	69.65	70.30	63.91	tbreaux
26	Wdo-coins UPDATED	90.48%	70.00	71.00	61.32	Wdo-coins
27	Prairie Gold 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 10 2018 2019 2020 2021 UPDATED	80.95%	70.00	71.00	58.09	RF
27	knovak1976 2021 2022 UPDATED	80.95%	70.00	71.00	58.09	knovak1976
27	George Craft UPDATED	80.95%	70.00	71.00	58.09	[email protected]
30	Fernando A. Baez Guerrero 2008 2009 2010 2011 2013 UPDATED	80.95%	69.94	70.89	58.00	fernandobaez
31	driftwood UPDATED	80.95%	69.00	69.00	56.45	driftwood
32	kbeeson 2020 2021 UPDATED	76.19%	70.00	71.00	54.86	kbeeson
33	brucehberman UPDATED	71.43%	69.88	70.75	51.45	[email protected]
34	Shiny Buffalo Proof $50 2018 2019 UPDATED	66.67%	70.00	71.00	48.41	dmb88
34	BS91367 2019 UPDATED	66.67%	70.00	71.00	48.41	BS91367
34	Hiho.x2 UPDATED	66.67%	70.00	71.00	48.41	Hiho.x2
37	popfligh UPDATED	61.90%	69.14	69.29	44.09	popfligh
38	JPV PF70 Buffalo UPDATED	57.14%	70.00	71.00	41.95	[email protected]
38	JCTS Buffaloes UPDATED	57.14%	70.00	71.00	41.95	BS91367
40	MarkBen 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 UPDATED	52.38%	70.00	71.00	38.73	MarkBen
40	fcpowell 2008 2016 UPDATED	52.38%	70.00	71.00	38.73	fcpowell
42	ChiefCy UPDATED	52.38%	69.92	70.83	38.64	IlliniCy
43	tom75 UPDATED	52.38%	69.83	70.67	38.55	tom75
44	fredl422 UPDATED	57.14%	69.58	70.17	38.27	[email protected]
45	fwheat 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 UPDATED	47.62%	70.00	71.00	35.50	fwheat
45	BK Spartan 2012 2013 2014 2015 UPDATED	47.62%	70.00	71.00	35.50	bk12345
45	Bear Creek Collection 2013 UPDATED	47.62%	70.00	71.00	35.50	BearCreek
48	BVS Gold Buffalo Collection #3 2013 2014 2015 UPDATED	42.86%	70.00	71.00	32.27	[email protected]
48	MGM Collection 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 UPDATED	42.86%	70.00	71.00	32.27	MGM
50	Proof Gold Buffalos UPDATED	42.86%	69.30	69.60	31.64	cliess
51	Dayton Flyer 2014 2015 UPDATED	42.86%	70.00	71.00	29.05	Unclepete
52	jcheng UPDATED	38.10%	69.67	70.33	28.77	jcheng
53	stinchfish UPDATED	38.10%	69.44	69.89	28.59	stinchfish
53	D.A. Re American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof 2006 - Present UPDATED	38.10%	69.44	69.89	28.59	DARMAR
55	TheKrogerCollection 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 UPDATED	33.33%	70.00	71.00	25.82	TheKrogerCollection
55	Uncle Trav E 2010 2011 2012 2013 UPDATED	33.33%	70.00	71.00	25.82	nedskape1
55	kmgken 2010 2011 2012 2013 UPDATED	33.33%	70.00	71.00	25.82	kmgken
55	The Twinight Collection 2011 2012 UPDATED	33.33%	70.00	R 71.00	25.82	TWINIGHT
59	DMW’s Show Me Your Proof Collection UPDATED	33.33%	70.00	71.00	22.59	Dustin
60	midcitiesbingo 2013 UPDATED	28.57%	70.00	71.00	22.59	Anonymous
61	cdfred UPDATED	28.57%	69.43	69.86	22.23	Clark Frederick
62	jimblasius UPDATED	28.57%	70.00	71.00	19.36	Jim Blasius
62	Buffalo Set UPDATED	28.57%	70.00	71.00	19.36	[email protected]
64	Mainor American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof (2006-present) 2008 2009 2010 UPDATED	23.81%	70.00	71.00	19.36	Anonymous
64	Prairiedoc 2009 2010 2011 UPDATED	23.81%	70.00	71.00	19.36	sjkottman
66	FredJoan (1) UPDATED	23.81%	69.33	69.67	19.00	FREDJOAN
67	spearme a proof gold Buffalo 🦬 UPDATED	28.57%	69.17	69.33	18.91	spearme
68	FredJoan (2) UPDATED	23.81%	69.17	69.33	18.91	FREDJOAN
69	FredJoan (3) UPDATED	23.81%	69.00	69.00	18.82	FREDJOAN
70	Moon's High 2015 UPDATED	23.81%	70.00	71.00	16.14	[email protected]
70	xpnsvewno 2009 2010 2011 2012 UPDATED	23.81%	70.00	71.00	16.14	xpnsvewno
72	Deegm 2008 2009 2010 UPDATED	19.05%	70.00	71.00	16.14	Deegm
72	Martz Collection 2010 UPDATED	19.05%	70.00	71.00	16.14	coin!!!!
72	Martz Collection 2 2010 UPDATED	19.05%	70.00	71.00	16.14	coin!!!!
75	thelondoncoincompany UPDATED	23.81%	69.80	70.60	16.05	thelondoncoincompany
76	Dscaple70 UPDATED	19.05%	69.60	70.20	15.95	Dscaple70
77	lrosen UPDATED	19.05%	70.00	71.00	12.91	[email protected]
77	BillofRights1791 UPDATED	19.05%	70.00	71.00	12.91	BillofRights1791
79	The BigSarge Collection 2007 2008 UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	R 71.00	12.91	big_sarge
79	floydhed 2007 2008 2009 UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	71.00	12.91	floydhed
79	Mint Mint Products 2008 2009 2010 2011 UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	71.00	12.91	jessewvu
79	Jefel's Buffaloes Madness 2008 2009 UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	71.00	12.91	holist
79	Rocky Mountain High Buffalo Stampede 2009 UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	R 71.00	12.91	dagasp
79	ebaymerchant 2009 UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	71.00	12.91	ebaymerchant
85	Cobsdo UPDATED	19.05%	69.75	70.50	12.82	[email protected]
86	phireman4 UPDATED	14.29%	69.75	70.50	12.82	phireman4
86	CMS Collection UPDATED	14.29%	69.75	70.50	12.82	csantoro
86	m4ctadas UPDATED	14.29%	69.75	70.50	12.82	m4ctadas
89	kadmd1 UPDATED	19.05%	69.00	69.50	12.64	[email protected]
89	MLMoore UPDATED	19.05%	69.25	69.50	12.64	MLMoore
91	Alcon UPDATED	19.05%	69.00	69.00	12.55	ksteele
92	goldbuff UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	71.00	09.68	[email protected]
92	Cowles UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	71.00	09.68	Cowles
92	llisser512 UPDATED	14.29%	70.00	71.00	09.68	llisser512
95	xpnsvewno (3) UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	09.68	xpnsvewno
96	Ron C. Collection UPDATED	14.29%	69.67	70.33	09.59	rcbowhuntr12
96	Fernando Baez Guerrero UPDATED	14.29%	69.67	70.33	09.59	fernandobaez
98	Collectoroldthings UPDATED	14.29%	69.33	69.67	09.50	Collectoroldthings
98	fnord123 UPDATED	14.29%	69.33	69.67	09.50	fnord123
98	lns1 UPDATED	14.29%	69.33	69.67	09.50	Havoc
98	alancc UPDATED	14.29%	69.33	69.67	09.50	[email protected]
98	Sterling Proof Buffaloes UPDATED	14.29%	69.33	69.67	09.50	Sterling
103	Gyros - First Strike 2007 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	gyro.mac
103	lotto1717 2007 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	lotto1717
103	Lake Wylie Collection UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	kragg
103	Bryan's PR70DCAM First Strike Set 2008 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	Guarnieri
103	The S. Trommler Jr. Collection UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	notjustrocks
103	mrherron69 2008 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	mrherron69
103	The Coleman Collection 2008 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	Coleman
103	KB Proof Buffalos 2008 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	kettymail
103	ElHajj UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	ELHAJJ
103	Gyros UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	gyro.mac
103	Southern Eagles UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	Southern Eagles
103	Coinboy's Blue Label Buffalo $50 Gold Proofs UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	R 71.00	06.45	COIN_BOY
103	kniky22 (2) YN 2008 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	kniky22
103	The Coleman Collection UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	Coleman
103	AJR 2012 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	AJR
103	rooksmith UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	rooksmith
103	bobcadez UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	bobcadez
103	stephenb317 UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	stephenb317
103	kniky22 YN UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	kniky22
103	RTB Collection - Gold Buffalo, Proof UPDATED	9.52%	70.00	71.00	06.45	tbarber
123	One Three's Buffalo Folly UPDATED	9.52%	69.50	70.00	06.36	TONEILL100
123	montyjams UPDATED	9.52%	69.50	R 70.00	06.36	montyjams
123	xpnsvewno (2) UPDATED	9.52%	69.50	R 70.00	06.36	xpnsvewno
123	franks78 UPDATED	9.52%	69.50	70.00	06.36	franks78
123	MBS American Buffalo $50 Proofs UPDATED	9.52%	69.50	70.00	06.36	mbstovall
123	Jim557 -- American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof UPDATED	9.52%	69.50	70.00	06.36	Jim557
129	ojhow268 Buster Howard UPDATED	9.52%	69.00	69.00	06.27	ojhow268
129	jackalfried UPDATED	9.52%	69.00	69.00	06.27	jackalfried
129	boatspless UPDATED	9.52%	69.00	69.00	06.27	boatspless
132	Where Have All the Buffalo Gone? UPDATED	4.76%	70.00	71.00	03.23	preddis