Modern Commemorative Dollars, Proof (1983-present) All-Time Finest List

Number of
Required Items
104
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
70.918

The commemorative dollars make for beautiful coins in the Proof format, as modern technology has created coins with heavy cameo contrast and superb strikes. This series is growing quickly, as are the fans for these unusual and sometimes controversial designs. The Columbus issue of 1992 and the Vietnam War Memorial issue of 1994 are among the most popular pieces.

Notes: This set has deductions. Please see the Set Composition for a listing.

All-Time Finest (All Eras)

Rank Set Name % Complete GPA Weighted GPA with Top
Pop Bonuses
Set Rating User
1 Subway Tokens Modern Commemorative Dollars Proof 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 100.00% 70.00 R 70.98 70.98
2 Goldminer's Collection 2017 2018 2020 2021 2022 2023 100.00% 69.97 R 70.95 70.95
3 The Good Collection 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 100.00% 69.92 70.90 70.90
4 Big Al 100.00% 69.85 70.77 70.77
5 MKeeler 100.00% 69.80 R 70.58 70.58
6 The Weber Collection ~ Commemorative Dollars UPDATED 100.00% 69.10 69.27 69.27
7 genoj 100.00% 69.05 69.19 69.19
8 5thwhl 100.00% 69.09 R 69.19 69.19
9 ErasmusHall 2025 96.15% 69.97 70.95 69.02
10 Modern Event Proof Dollars 100.00% 69.01 R 69.02 69.02
11 Kazman54 - Modern Commemorative Dollars, Proof (1983-present) 99.04% 69.07 69.21 68.74
12 DW Commemorative Dollar PR (1983-Present) 100.00% 68.42 68.52 68.52
13 Amanda.klatt 95.19% 69.87 70.79 68.38
14 Pollard Modern Commemorative Proof Dollars 95.70% 69.31 R 69.64 67.59
15 Fluer de Coin Collection YN 95.77% 69.46 R 69.93 67.47
16 coe comm. 96.15% 69.03 69.13 67.25
coe
17 Card's Coins 92.31% 69.87 70.76 66.90
18 CCcoiner 91.35% 69.96 70.93 66.59
19 jackalfried 94.23% 69.13 69.29 66.46
20 The Robert B. Lewis Collection 91.35% 69.88 70.78 66.45
21 The Comer Collection 93.33% 69.18 R 69.35 66.42
22 metel38 proof dollars 90.38% 69.90 70.81 65.99
23 Heywoods Proof $ Commems 91.78% 69.22 R 69.44 65.84
24 Otto Flynt 3/25. Blk Bg ? 92.31% 69.07 69.16 65.39
25 The Gray Collection 92.31% 69.02 69.07 65.31
26 Sam's Modern Comm's Proof Dollars 2008 2009 88.46% 69.88 70.78 65.00
27 Jesse's Modern Commemorative Proof Dollars 90.41% 69.05 R 69.09 64.92
28 Horner Commems $1 PR 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 87.50% 70.00 70.98 64.70
29 Jayne Shelby Collection 89.42% 69.42 69.85 64.63
30 SOlsonBFDL14 90.38% 69.02 69.07 64.37
31 lostmountainman 85.58% 69.92 70.83 63.60
32 The Derek Collection 87.50% 69.20 69.42 63.28
33 CMP0369 91.35% 69.91 70.91 62.71
34 Big D Brass 83.65% 69.95 70.87 62.67
35 Barton Collection 85.58% 69.10 69.20 62.14
36 drkilmer 85.58% 68.63 68.71 61.70
37 PMH 84.62% 68.98 69.02 61.50
PMH
38 numismatist 81.73% 68.86 69.04 60.12
39 WAW Commemoratives 85.58% 69.97 70.96 59.86
40 randycoins 80.77% 69.13 69.25 59.83
41 Chucks Modern Commemorative Dollars, Proof (1983-present) 82.69% 68.61 68.74 59.39
42 bobdock 84.62% 69.96 70.93 59.35
43 JRs Coins 79.81% 69.11 69.25 59.35
44 RT’s Modern-Comm S.$1 Proof (PR69-70DCAM). 78.85% 69.25 69.49 59.09
45 Ozarko Collection 76.92% 69.41 69.83 58.43
46 anthonyd117 YN 77.88% 68.88 69.01 58.21
47 jasonpwagner 76.92% 69.23 69.44 58.10
48 Two Bit Texan 77.88% 69.03 69.07 57.79
49 goofydog 75.00% 69.04 69.07 56.86
50 bbergmann 74.04% 69.30 69.60 56.82
51 The Oregon Trail Collection, Tony's Commemoratives / PR 74.04% 69.28 69.55 56.78
52 The DS Collection 74.04% 69.14 69.27 56.54
53 [email protected] 76.92% 69.03 69.07 56.38
54 Tony's Silver Dollars 74.04% 70.00 70.97 56.01
55 For my Grandchildren 70.19% 69.79 70.59 55.70
56 KingOldie's Modern Commemorative Dollars, Proof 71.15% 69.01 69.02 54.93
56 Buffalo Mountain Collection 71.15% 69.01 69.02 54.93
58 Herb's Proof Comm Silver Dollar 70.19% 69.01 69.02 54.46
59 bgdurango 71.15% 69.00 69.00 54.45
60 MidwestCollector 68.27% 69.21 69.42 53.84
61 KansasProspector 76.92% 69.91 70.83 53.48
62 Bear Creek Collection 66.35% 69.08 69.16 52.69
63 Jim557 - Modern Commemorative Dollars Proof (1983-Present) 68.27% 68.97 69.04 52.60
64 Weatherman Modern Commemorative Dollars Proof 66.35% 69.02 69.04 52.60
65 rjcent 62.50% 69.03 69.06 50.74
66 guccieng 72.12% 69.95 70.92 50.66
67 Grayanimal47 62.50% 69.29 69.58 50.65
68 The Nelson Collection 60.58% 69.49 69.98 50.46
69 The Carter Collection 60.58% 69.07 R 69.13 49.85
70 bgray7809 69.23% 68.93 69.05 49.32
71 JB3 Collection 58.65% 69.35 69.69 49.31
72 Tim's Bits Of History 59.62% 69.00 R 69.00 49.29
73 Malibu Collection 58.65% 69.20 69.40 49.10
74 Mac and Sally's Modern Commem Proof Dollars 58.65% 69.08 69.15 48.93
75 Modern Treasures 58.65% 69.07 69.13 48.91
76 Goodson #1 58.65% 69.04 69.08 48.87
77 Hauser Collection 58.65% 68.88 68.88 48.73
MLH
78 karencochran56 63.46% 68.73 68.82 48.69
79 Bill Pollard Commemorative Proof Dollars 1983 to Present 57.69% 69.04 R 69.08 48.40
80 BillPat ModernCommerative PR69 $1 57.69% 69.00 69.00 48.35
81 LA Collection 56.73% 69.16 R 69.31 48.10
82 Somerville Set 56.73% 69.00 R 69.00 47.88
83 cheng 55.77% 69.00 R 69.00 47.41
83 HeRo * * * * * * * * * * 55.77% 69.00 R 69.00 47.41
85 Save The Planet Dudes! 56.73% 69.01 69.02 46.95
86 The Ia Drang Valley Silver Commemoratives $1 Proof Collection 54.81% 69.01 R 69.02 46.95
86 DWS 54.81% 69.01 69.02 46.95
88 The Fahnoe Collection 2007 52.88% 69.71 R 70.43 46.95
89 Manos73 55.77% 69.00 69.00 46.94
90 Princess Ellaina Proof $1 Comm. Collection 53.85% 69.03 69.06 46.51
91 ashmore86 56.73% 69.01 69.02 46.48
92 Scott Hadlock 53.85% 69.00 R 69.00 46.47
92 Plasticman 53.85% 69.00 R 69.00 46.47
92 numiZmatics - ModComm Proof Dollars 53.85% 69.00 69.00 46.47
92 Sixty-Nine Proof Bucks 53.85% 69.00 69.00 46.47
96 The PK Collection 55.77% 67.53 67.62 46.46
97 Allen Seltzer Collection 51.92% 69.45 R 69.91 46.13
98 Sant's Modern Dollar Proof Commemoratives 52.88% 69.03 69.06 46.04
99 Gene B. collection 52.88% 69.00 R 69.00 46.00
99 Johnfen Collection 52.88% 69.00 69.00 46.00
101 Leno Dollar 51.92% 69.00 69.00 45.53
102 RFW 2003 2004 49.04% 69.52 R 70.04 44.79
103 Ferreira Collection 58.65% 68.80 68.88 44.52
104 The Driscoll Modern Commemorative Proof Collection 50.96% 69.01 R 69.02 44.14
105 Edward Mikel Twenter 49.04% 69.01 69.02 44.14
106 Robert Kaye Modern Commem Proof Dollar 49.04% 69.00 R 69.00 44.12
107 CLBs Modern Commemorative Dollars Proof Set 49.04% 68.93 R 68.93 44.07
108 Andrea Lijoi collection 48.08% 69.20 R 69.41 43.91
109 Zawadzki Family Proof Set 53.85% 69.12 69.24 43.80
110 Cowles Coins 50.96% 69.03 69.06 43.69
111 Brian David Ltd 48.08% 69.00 69.00 43.65
112 CBD Collection 49.04% 68.11 68.11 43.55
CBD
113 Roger's Collection 47.12% 69.03 R 69.07 43.22
114 Jeffrey's Modern Commems 50.96% 69.02 69.04 43.21
115 Sterling's Dollar Commem's PR 48.08% 69.00 R 69.00 43.18
116 Opa's 47.12% 69.00 R 69.00 43.18
Opa
116 The Ramsey Collection 47.12% 69.00 R 69.00 43.18
116 The David & Karen Linton Collection 47.12% 69.00 R 69.00 43.18
116 The Silver Silver Collection 47.12% 69.00 R 69.00 43.18
120 96W 50.96% 68.73 68.73 43.01
121 PF69 Jim Vyskocil 49.04% 69.00 69.00 42.24
122 Chuck's Modern Commems $1 Proof Strike 45.19% 69.00 69.00 42.24
123 The Spallina Collection 44.23% 69.00 R 69.00 41.78
123 The Wihlborg Collection 44.23% 69.00 R 69.00 41.78
123 Gibbs Collection 44.23% 69.00 R 69.00 41.78
123 Haynes Collection 44.23% 69.00 69.00 41.78
123 Gibbs Kangarooo Collection 44.23% 69.00 69.00 41.78
128 Doug's Coins 43.27% 69.02 R 69.05 41.33
129 Mike Davidson Collection 43.27% 69.00 R 69.00 41.31
130 school-man 46.15% 69.00 69.02 40.85
131 Henderson Family Collection 43.27% 69.00 R 69.00 40.84
132 AlexB 49.04% 69.01 69.06 36.65
133 NLJ Collection Modern Comm Proofs 42.31% 69.21 69.42 36.36
134 The Robert M. Collection 51.92% 69.54 70.12 36.25
135 gobluejackets 44.23% 68.96 68.97 36.13
136 Scotty's PR70 Modern Commemorative $1 51.92% 70.00 70.99 35.73
137 barneydj 40.38% 68.84 68.89 34.21
138 Jimnukem 49.04% 70.00 70.99 33.80
139 Hogan Collection: Modern Commemorative Silver Dollars - Proof 47.12% 68.68 69.44 33.54
140 Silverhistory 42.31% 68.85 68.89 33.27
141 Scott's One Dollar---PR69---Commem's 42.31% 68.99 69.00 32.86
142 Alexander F. Neefus Collection 43.27% 69.10 69.42 32.59
143 The Treehouse Commemoratives Silver Dollar Proofs 32.69% 69.00 69.00 31.92
144 RC4Ken 40.38% 69.00 69.00 31.45
145 TheHistorian 41.35% 69.03 69.06 31.01
146 Spacy's Collection 34.62% 69.02 69.03 30.05
147 sage03 40.38% 68.47 68.55 29.84
148 HChilds 45.19% 69.15 69.49 28.84
149 andex 35.58% 69.10 69.33 28.30
150 Jimmy King Collection 33.65% 69.00 69.00 28.16
151 talk2thephin13 42.31% 68.80 68.85 28.10
152 friedmad 34.62% 69.07 69.12 26.80
153 Myeackle 35.58% 69.04 69.09 26.79
154 fwheat 34.62% 68.96 69.14 26.34
155 terreb 35.58% 69.05 69.13 26.33
156 Topscot's Modern Commemorative Dollars, Proof (1983-present) 50.00% 69.04 69.35 25.48
157 The T.F. Schaub, Jr. Collection 37.50% 69.02 69.04 25.36
158 texasbest 39.42% 69.58 70.32 25.35
159 crosson47 31.73% 68.87 68.98 24.87
160 Barakka's 32.69% 68.60 68.66 24.76
161 Callahan427 44.23% 69.84 70.82 24.57
162 One Three's Silver Folly 27.88% 68.87 68.87 24.36
163 LJK's Modern Commemorative Dollars - Proof Collection 36.54% 69.66 70.32 23.92
164 Fortune8 31.73% 70.00 70.98 23.18
165 ccolli13 28.85% 68.98 69.04 22.54
166 felinfoel 29.81% 69.00 69.00 22.06
167 Rudolph Coins 28.85% 69.95 70.89 21.22
168 john.bennett 30.77% 69.07 69.29 19.80
169 Mark's Modern Commemorative Dollars Proof Set 39.42% 68.88 69.10 19.74
170 wolffish1972 25.96% 68.88 68.90 19.69
171 Diamond Heart - NM 22.12% 67.51 67.51 18.83
172 WrigleySoldierBears 25.00% 69.00 69.00 18.78
173 jody1 21.15% 69.00 69.00 18.78
174 Dave Ernst 27.88% 69.18 69.44 18.42
175 matkins079 29.81% 68.90 69.00 18.31
176 Wojcikowski Collection 23.08% 69.29 69.58 17.99
177 MAT & GMT Collection 23.08% 68.87 68.87 17.80
178 Fogbear's Proof Modern Commemorative Dollars UPDATED 24.04% 69.35 69.70 17.54
179 WCF Modern Commemorative Dollar Proof 21.15% 69.08 69.16 17.41
180 Bill Bellamy 21.15% 68.94 69.08 16.92
181 ilovepcgs 21.15% 69.00 69.00 16.90
182 jemorris50 29.81% 68.77 69.06 16.44
183 Bugnbass 18.27% 69.00 69.00 16.43
184 jumpup88 25.96% 69.35 69.85 16.16
185 Beauregard2021 22.12% 68.88 69.00 15.96
186 Abrego Collection Commemorative Silver Dollar Proofs 20.19% 69.00 69.00 15.96
187 mgmueller22 21.15% 69.06 69.12 15.52
188 rustynailboutique 18.27% 68.94 68.94 15.01
189 Stockman 23.08% 69.39 69.77 14.71
190 Princess Flor Modern Commemorative $1, PR69 (1983 - Present) 24.04% 69.00 69.00 14.55
191 Tornado Proof Dollars (all PR69's) YN 17.31% 69.00 69.00 14.55
192 jasblum 20.19% 69.87 70.87 14.46
193 Plasticman 24.04% 69.60 70.57 14.40
194 Powhatan Proofs 15.38% 69.67 70.33 14.35
195 GSC 26.92% 69.48 70.10 13.83
GSC
196 Saltwater Investments 20.19% 69.93 70.86 13.50
197 cardinalfan 16.35% 69.19 69.37 12.74
198 Mike's Commorative Dollars 13.46% 68.96 68.96 12.67
199 Leeder's Modern Commemorative Dollars, Proof (1983-present) 21.15% 69.08 69.62 12.31
200 DurfCoin 13.46% 69.00 69.00 12.20
201 Howard Collection 16.35% 70.00 71.00 12.07
202 combatmailman 17.31% 68.19 68.23 12.07
203 RoLiki 20.19% 69.76 70.68 12.02
204 Macky's Collection 13.46% 69.00 69.00 11.73
205 J.D.'s Comm Proof Dollars 17.31% 69.00 69.00 11.27
206 KT - Modern Comm Dollars Proof 13.46% 70.00 70.95 10.62
207 heartwoman 15.38% 68.91 68.95 10.32
208 XXX 13.46% 68.68 68.68 10.28
XXX
209 m4ctadas 18.27% 68.39 68.57 10.26
210 GRC Modern Commemorative Dollars, Proof 1983-Present 16.35% 69.00 69.00 09.86
211 Fernando Baez Guerrero 12.50% 68.20 68.65 09.34
212 ajia 11.54% 68.89 68.89 08.90
213 Nepras 14.42% 70.00 71.00 08.69
214 ‘96 Collection - Modern Commemorative Proofs 9.62% 69.17 69.56 08.52
215 maqz99 YN 14.42% 68.94 69.17 08.47
216 Hawks7 11.54% 69.00 69.00 08.45
217 USMC Collection 15.38% 70.00 71.00 08.21
217 roadwarrior1101 15.38% 70.00 71.00 08.21
219 taxminnow 10.58% 69.00 69.00 07.98
220 krad 9.62% 69.00 69.00 07.98
221 Dixiepig 12.50% 69.69 70.25 07.65
222 jas68 12.50% 69.44 70.00 07.62
223 Jackson Family Collection 9.62% 69.13 69.69 07.59
224 Proof Comm Dollars 1983-Present - Cr2153 11.54% 69.19 69.63 07.58
225 rancidronen 11.54% 69.00 69.00 07.51
226 The Juno Collection 9.62% 69.00 69.00 07.51
227 QualityCoins 999 Estate 14.42% 69.53 70.07 07.15
228 Snovacc 10.58% 69.07 69.13 07.05
229 DLP Modern Com Proof Dollar Set 8.65% 69.07 69.14 06.59
230 The Swenson Modern Proof Silver Dollar Commemerative Collection 8.65% 68.43 68.43 06.52
231 rickbickel 8.65% 68.14 68.14 06.49
232 EAGLE KING 12.50% 69.38 70.31 06.22
233 kriskallaway1 9.62% 69.23 69.54 06.15
234 yellow_habanero 8.65% 69.00 69.00 06.10
234 Winnie50021 8.65% 69.00 69.00 06.10
236 Rob Walls 10.58% 70.00 71.00 05.80
237 When dollars make sense 9.62% 69.67 70.42 05.75
238 derollins 11.54% 69.00 70.00 05.71
239 mikelesa 9.62% 69.18 69.73 05.22
240 Kenyon's Koins 8.65% 69.00 69.00 05.16
241 Princess Flor Modern Commemorative $1, PR70 (1983 - Present) 9.62% 70.00 71.00 04.83
242 danvic01 UPDATED 8.65% 69.60 70.60 04.80
243 [email protected] 7.69% 69.60 70.60 04.80
244 maindish99 8.65% 69.10 69.20 04.71
245 Michigantaco 5.77% 69.10 69.20 04.71
246 boccman 8.65% 69.00 69.00 04.69
247 Modern Commem Dollars, Proof (1983-Present) 7.69% 69.44 70.11 04.29
248 Coolstone Collection 5.77% 69.38 69.63 03.79
249 CoinGuy1999 5.77% 69.13 69.13 03.76
250 ArkJones 4.81% 69.43 69.86 03.33
251 jserra1957 4.81% 69.50 70.00 02.86
251 markrovelli 4.81% 69.50 70.00 02.86
253 VAL1632199 UPDATED 4.81% 69.33 69.67 02.84
254 Theoprime 5.77% 68.83 69.33 02.83
254 zorknapp 5.77% 68.83 69.33 02.83
256 nickmd18 3.85% 68.67 68.83 02.81
257 Ivan.Tichenor 2.88% 69.20 69.40 02.36
258 jakevolkman 2.88% 69.00 69.00 02.35
259 Neibaur Family Collection II 3.85% 69.00 70.00 01.90
260 RomaniIteDomum 2.88% 69.00 69.00 01.88
260 RoadRunner60 2.88% 68.75 69.00 01.88
262 Bill Bellamy (2) 1.92% 69.00 69.00 01.88
263 Selly53 2.88% 70.00 71.00 01.45
264 Ryanrayborn1791 1.92% 70.00 71.00 01.45
265 BillW804 2.88% 70.00 70.33 01.44
265 nevinc 2.88% 69.67 70.33 01.44
267 chanceduncan 2.88% 69.67 70.00 01.43
268 Sockerref 1.92% 70.00 71.00 00.97
268 MaximumSamurai 1.92% 70.00 71.00 00.97
270 CCcoiner (2) 0.96% 70.00 71.00 00.97
271 pat4president1996 1.92% 70.00 70.50 00.96
272 corky 1.92% 70.00 70.00 00.95
272 [email protected] 1.92% 69.50 70.00 00.95
274 Fauxhead Modern Commemorative Dollars 1.92% 69.00 69.00 00.94
274 Greatstuff2543 1.92% 68.00 69.00 00.94
276 Humble House 0.96% 70.00 71.00 00.48
276 Commemorative Dollars 0.96% 70.00 71.00 00.48
276 Thomadams 0.96% 70.00 71.00 00.48
279 Plaza Mayor 0.96% 69.00 69.00 00.47
279 ML55 Modern Commem Silver Dollars NEW 0.96% 69.00 69.00 00.47