Trade Dollars with Major Varieties, Circulation Strikes (1873-1878) All-Time Finest List

Number of
Required Items
18
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
67.943
Set Composition
Start This Set

A short but extremely challenging series that is LOADED with condition rarities. In fact, none of the coins can be called "common." The stoppers of the series include the 1875, 1876-CC, 1877-CC, and 1878-CC, but many other dates could be added to the list depending on the condition. This is one of America's most historic and interesting coins, and in gem condition it is beautiful as well.

All-Time Finest (All Eras)

View PCGS Era
Rank Set Name % Complete GPA Weighted GPA with Top
Pop Bonuses		 Set Rating User
1 Legend Collection HOF 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2011 2012 2013 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 100.00% 65.93 R 67.74 67.74
tradedollarnut
1 Black Cat Trade Dollars with Major Varieties, Circulation Strikes (1873-1878) 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 100.00% 65.93 67.74 67.74
Black Cat
3 D. L. Hansen Trade Dollars with Major Varieties, Circulation Strikes (1873-1878) 2017 100.00% 64.41 R 64.55 64.55
DLH
4 MnS Joint Venture 100.00% 64.00 R 64.00 64.00
spetty
5 A.W. Collection 100.00% 63.83 R 63.83 63.83
AW Collection
6 Trader 1873 100.00% 62.44 R 62.44 62.44
Trader1873
7 Natural Trade Dollars 100.00% 60.98 60.98 60.98
Hagop
8 The Baltimore Set 94.44% 62.77 62.77 60.61
apharris
9 Willem Collection 100.00% 59.64 R 59.64 59.64
Willem
10 No Chops Allowed! 100.00% 59.49 59.49 59.49
History in you’re hands
11 Concord Collection 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 88.89% 62.60 62.60 59.00
keoj
12 420Grains 100.00% 57.86 57.86 57.86
sdmjam
13 Arizona Collection 94.44% 59.74 R 59.74 53.56
MICHAELMAGDIC
14 derf21 100.00% 52.80 52.80 52.80
derf21
15 Everyman Trade Dollars, Circulation Strikes 100.00% 52.44 R 52.44 52.44
BarrowTH
16 Louis Eliasberg 94.44% 57.28 R 57.31 51.38
Louis Eliasberg
17 Quiver Collection 94.44% 57.22 57.22 51.30
Quiver Collectibles
18 Reel Coug Best Trade $ 88.89% 56.86 56.86 47.71
Reel Coug
19 The Zambezi Collection 94.44% 50.78 50.78 46.69
jkurtenbach
20 Old Chelsea 94.44% 45.00 R 45.00 43.45
friedfrank11
21 CC_Collection 66.67% 49.10 49.10 34.99
CC_Collection
22 Precious Times 38.89% 58.05 58.05 26.69
Precious Time & Metals
23 Fernando Baez Guerrero 66.67% 63.21 63.21 23.98
fernandobaez
24 BlitzBiker2001 72.22% 40.00 40.00 21.15
BlitzBiker2001
25 M&M's 44.44% 61.31 61.31 19.03
[email protected]
26 markcobble 50.00% 37.27 37.27 18.85
[email protected]
27 BigBrushy-120 61.11% 37.51 37.51 15.95
[email protected]
28 lostmountainman 55.56% 47.81 47.81 14.29
lostmountainman
29 20youksox 33.33% 44.76 44.76 10.80
20youksox
30 Gooselx48 Trade Dollars 27.78% 49.33 49.33 10.21
gooselx48
31 Falcon178 38.89% 51.77 51.77 07.74
Falcon178
32 Evergreen 50.00% 16.19 16.19 05.02
Evergreen
33 [email protected] 27.78% 44.22 44.22 04.57
Anonymous
34 MADELINE 33.33% 28.67 28.67 03.95
carstand
35 melchionne1 11.11% 27.36 27.36 03.46
melchionne1
36 The DFT Trade Dollars, Circulation Strikes Collection 16.67% 42.50 42.50 02.93
Maesto119
37 Southcounty Collection 22.22% 35.71 35.71 02.87
trymenc
38 mcarskaddon 11.11% 41.00 41.00 02.36
[email protected]
39 KENWMAC7 11.11% 37.50 37.50 01.72
[email protected]