I had to pony up for this puppy!
Gordon Wrubel: Quickfinder Notes: The Small Date variety is distinguished by the PLAIN ending to the crossbar on the 4. The Medium Date variety has larger numerals and the crossbar of the 4 ends in a CROSSLET. The Small Date is about two and a half times scarcer than the Medium Date. See coin #6241 for the extremely rare 1842 Small Date, Reverse of 1839.
Heritage 1/2015:3135, $25,850
David Schweitz, sold privately in 7/2008 - Eugene H. Gardner Collection - Heritage 6/2014:30485, $9,693.75