Buffalo Nickels Date Set, Circulation Strikes (1913-1938) Current Finest List

Number of
Required Items

Current Finest
Possible Set Rating

67.750

There is something about Buffalo nickels that attracts collectors. Some collectors remember when every once in a while one would show up in their change, or a time when they did grandpa a favor and the reward was a beautiful old nickel. Perhaps it reminds us of a time when the West was still new. Whatever the reasons, many people collect Buffalo nickels and some have managed to build truly phenomenal sets. This Basic set is the easiest entry into this popular area of numismatics. Comprised of one coin from each date, it is able to avoid the tough key dates (usually the "S" mints from the 1920s. For that reason, it is quite easy to complete and will make a beautiful display if done in high grade.

Current Finest

Rank	Set Name	% Complete	GPA Weighted	Set Rating	User
1	JDG Trust Collection 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025	100.00%	67.65	67.65	lunagately
2	Gerald Forsythe 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2013 2014 2015 2016 10 2017 2018 2019 2020	100.00%	67.57	67.57	FORSYTHEG
3	Rafus Buffalo Date Set	100.00%	67.23	67.23	Rafus
3	Teton buffaloes date set	100.00%	67.23	67.23	bbuckner
5	Gosnell Collection 2015 2016 2017	100.00%	67.20	67.20	Anonymous
6	The Grand Cru Collection	100.00%	67.14	67.14	Love Collector
7	Bubba's Buffalo Nickel Date Set	100.00%	66.91	66.91	Bubba's Coins
8	KCV date set Herd 2014	100.00%	66.73	66.73	kurtskoins
9	William E. Corum	100.00%	66.63	66.63	bulincs
10	Arizona Buffalos	100.00%	66.45	66.45	jweintraub
11	WheelingWV	100.00%	66.42	66.42	WheelingWV
12	A Brown’s Black Diamond Mine CIRC. Date Set UPDATED	100.00%	66.33	66.33	Black Diamond Mine
13	Buffalo Hunter	100.00%	66.11	66.11	Buffalo Hunter
14	Redfisharmy Buffs	100.00%	66.10	66.10	redfisharmy
15	CoolKarma Buffalo Date Set	100.00%	65.98	65.98	CoolKarma
16	Lindsay	100.00%	65.63	65.63	Lindsay
16	lostmountainman	100.00%	65.63	65.63	lostmountainman
18	JReevesTx	100.00%	65.61	65.61	JReevesTx
19	Red Oak(fun set)	100.00%	65.57	65.57	rwudi
20	Buckeye's Gem Buff Date Herd	100.00%	65.50	65.50	Anonymous
21	Freddoc	100.00%	65.40	65.40	Freddoc
22	Wineman	100.00%	65.37	65.37	myeatts
23	Buffalohunter's Herd	100.00%	65.26	65.26	buffalohunter
24	adpbuffs	100.00%	65.17	65.17	DUPH
25	driftwood Buffalo nickels date set MS	100.00%	65.13	65.13	driftwood
26	ChrisH821 Buffalo Date Set	100.00%	65.12	65.12	ChrisH821
27	danical57	100.00%	65.00	65.00	danical57
28	supamonk	100.00%	64.68	64.68	supamonk
29	A2Buffaloes UPDATED	100.00%	64.60	64.60	KB's coins
30	Jim's One-a-year Buffaloes	100.00%	64.41	64.41	jmconklin
31	Tim's Buffalo Nickel Date Set	100.00%	64.30	64.30	[email protected]
32	dgooch	100.00%	64.26	64.26	dgooch
33	M J Hess Collections- Buffalo - Date Set	100.00%	64.20	64.20	mjhess
34	Los Gatos Collection	100.00%	64.01	64.01	Los Gatos Collection
35	CCcoiner	100.00%	63.78	63.78	CCcoiner
36	gthorn4549	100.00%	63.70	63.70	[email protected]
37	KRP BUFFALOS	100.00%	63.66	63.66	KRP BUFFALOS
38	Bad Habit	95.65%	65.04	63.63	Bad Habit
39	Ozark's Thundering Herd 1	100.00%	63.26	63.26	mokando
40	ad4400	100.00%	63.08	63.08	[email protected]
41	The Wydeven Collection-TRUEVIEW Herd	100.00%	62.95	62.95	Ted III
42	Obsidian	95.65%	65.69	62.84	Obsidian
43	alr007	95.65%	62.35	58.28	alr007
44	Bryan's Set	95.65%	59.45	56.87	bruinbulldog
45	Buffalo Brothers Date Set	91.30%	61.96	56.58	BuffaloBrothersCoin
46	mrbigglesworth_2	95.65%	58.77	56.22	[email protected]
47	Longacre59	91.30%	62.99	56.14	Longacre59
48	TibbyDe	86.96%	65.96	55.92	TibbyDe
49	Connecticoin	91.30%	61.10	54.46	Connecticoin
50	Bison1959	100.00%	54.45	54.45	Bison1959
51	CBH Buffalo Nickels	73.91%	65.76	54.33	chiefmaxell
52	Miearspharmacy	86.96%	65.74	54.30	Miearspharmacy
53	Ryan795	100.00%	54.26	54.26	Ryan795
54	C Collins - Buffalo Nickels 1913-38	82.61%	62.03	53.93	ccc9660
55	DMTreger	82.61%	65.19	52.43	DMTreger
56	BigBrushy-120	91.30%	58.24	51.91	[email protected]
57	Starbuy	78.26%	64.27	51.70	Starbuy
58	sby999	86.96%	64.19	51.63	sby999
59	TLR Buffalo Nickels - Date Set	86.96%	60.23	51.07	TLR
60	obxpond	82.61%	64.69	50.63	ponderit
61	BZcoin	100.00%	49.39	49.39	BZcoin
62	Cat's Buffalo Date Set	78.26%	64.48	46.26	[email protected]
63	Tjbenoit0507	100.00%	46.11	46.11	Tjbenoit0507
64	Aspie-Rocco	100.00%	45.83	45.83	Aspie-Rocco
65	pfeiffen	78.26%	57.24	44.79	[email protected]
66	Jerry’s Buffalo Herd	73.91%	63.69	44.30	Commemlover57
67	The Raines Collection	82.61%	53.45	44.15	rainesrm3
68	johnshrieves	100.00%	44.09	44.09	johnshrieves
69	shsusa Buffalo 5C Date Circ 1913-38	73.91%	64.16	43.24	shsusa
70	TJA	60.87%	65.43	42.67	TIMALLEN
71	ckhowell	69.57%	65.07	41.02	ckhowell
72	john.bennett	100.00%	38.76	38.76	[email protected]
73	RickyRacer	78.26%	50.41	37.26	RickyRacer
74	Big Al's Buffs	52.17%	66.42	36.10	[email protected]
75	zstones7	60.87%	65.12	35.39	zstones7
76	Joegranados1969	52.17%	64.50	35.05	Joegranados1969
77	mayflower	65.22%	55.45	34.96	mayflower
78	[email protected]	56.52%	65.75	34.30	Todd
79	dominic	56.52%	65.10	33.97	[email protected]
80	The Gypsy Collection	56.52%	64.77	33.79	Jesh
81	Fogbear's Buffalo Nickels Date Set	69.57%	45.62	33.72	fogbearsf
82	Golden Collection Registry	52.17%	65.02	32.51	[email protected]
83	Bear Creek Collection	52.17%	64.73	30.96	BearCreek
84	ironmanl63	47.83%	64.38	29.39	[email protected]
85	boraoul	56.52%	52.82	28.71	boraoul
86	Terry"s Buffalo Herd Date Set	52.17%	64.70	28.13	tmlawes
87	R Castelino	43.48%	66.66	27.53	Anonymous
88	[email protected]	47.83%	65.29	26.97	Anonymous
89	Tatanka by Henry Goodnight and Bovidae	43.48%	64.89	26.80	qnagle
90	Au Buff Set	43.48%	52.96	26.48	Anonymous
91	docINnyc Nickels	52.17%	60.75	26.41	[email protected]
92	[email protected]	43.48%	54.09	25.87	Smithrow
93	emptypockets	52.17%	59.20	25.74	emptypockets
94	obxpond (2)	47.83%	64.78	25.35	ponderit
95	TD Buffalo 5c Date Set MS (1913-1938)	47.83%	50.61	25.30	[email protected]
96	michaelkp	52.17%	52.27	25.00	michaelkp
97	Lennonj	39.13%	66.03	24.40	Lennonj
98	Cascade Buffalo Date Set	60.87%	39.89	24.28	Cascade
99	romanose05	34.78%	63.29	23.39	romanose05
100	fredl422	52.17%	47.82	22.87	[email protected]
101	J & D COLLECTS	43.48%	64.38	22.39	J & D COLLECTS
102	jmb063	60.87%	40.56	22.04	jmb063
103	TEG Collection	39.13%	65.60	21.39	tgnagey
104	Hiitsart	69.57%	29.76	21.35	Hiitsart
105	DBRC Rainbow Toned Buffalo Nickel Date Set	39.13%	65.07	21.22	DEMPSEY&BAXTERRC
106	Mike	39.13%	64.13	20.91	Mike
107	Lbonser	43.48%	54.41	20.11	Lbonser
108	la662	39.13%	53.24	19.67	[email protected]
109	ajia	73.91%	26.15	18.76	ajia
110	Eric's Buffalo Nickels	34.78%	65.77	18.59	kareparr
111	Cen-Cal	34.78%	64.38	18.20	Cen-Cal
112	Tye	30.43%	65.17	17.00	Tye
113	talk2thephin13	34.78%	62.33	16.26	[email protected]
114	Numismatist Enthusiast69	30.43%	64.45	15.41	Numismatist Enthusiast69
115	[email protected]	30.43%	63.82	15.26	SCOTTYP
116	kola515	21.74%	62.45	14.93	kola515
117	Z	26.09%	67.40	14.65	Z
118	bricklayers5ny	30.43%	65.10	14.15	bricklayers5ny
119	TigersFan	43.48%	35.72	13.98	TigersFan
120	STEVEK	39.13%	36.59	13.52	STEVEK
121	nosam	52.17%	26.39	13.20	nosam
122	Tracy Jackson	30.43%	60.40	13.13	Tralee72
123	DAcoin	26.09%	66.00	12.91	DAcoin
124	Killmor	21.74%	66.00	12.91	Killmor
125	[email protected] UPDATED	47.83%	27.19	12.41	Anonymous
126	jmm483	43.48%	32.88	12.15	jmm483
127	Buffalo Nickels Circulation Strike	21.74%	65.13	11.33	drears
128	JScottWeber Buffalo Date Set	21.74%	64.75	11.26	JScott
129	pat4president1996	21.74%	64.13	11.15	pat4president1996
130	USCoinWholesalers	26.09%	59.00	10.26	USCoinWholesalers
131	Oberhaus Collection	21.74%	66.71	10.15	Oberhaus Collection
132	gary.salzer	21.74%	66.29	10.09	[email protected]
133	De2k51	21.74%	64.71	09.85	De2k51
134	mattward513	21.74%	58.50	08.90	mattward513
135	Vinny Kid	95.65%	9.00	08.80	Vinny Kid
136	gnorwood	17.39%	66.33	08.65	gnorwood
137	Bugman512	13.04%	66.25	08.64	Bugman512
138	timcarroll22	21.74%	65.33	08.52	timcarroll22
139	klenker13	17.39%	65.33	08.52	klenker13
140	papabee55	17.39%	65.00	08.48	papabee55
141	delmolino	13.04%	65.00	08.48	delmolino
142	njf	17.39%	64.17	08.37	njf
143	nawrockic	21.74%	63.67	08.30	nawrockic
144	MMitchell	43.48%	17.70	07.70	MMitchell
145	sanjoseslug	17.39%	41.25	07.17	sanjoseslug
146	jwalterholland	17.39%	65.60	07.13	[email protected]
147	Baustjj	17.39%	64.80	07.04	Baustjj
148	Barnhatt YN	13.04%	64.00	06.96	[email protected]
149	jboneny25 YN	17.39%	51.33	06.70	jboneny25
150	Chevelle67	17.39%	56.60	06.15	Chevelle67
151	Sam Martin	13.04%	66.38	05.77	sammis921
152	zorknapp	21.74%	32.75	05.70	zorknapp
153	IPLUMBU	13.04%	65.25	05.67	IPLUMBU
154	john doe	13.04%	65.00	05.65	john doe
155	ApexCollecting.com	21.74%	32.25	05.61	Apex Collecting
156	Ryguy21	8.70%	64.50	05.61	Ryguy21
157	Thoward91	13.04%	42.17	05.50	Thomas Howard
158	asinfrank	13.04%	44.00	04.78	[email protected]
159	WMP	13.04%	43.20	04.70	WMP
160	A. R. S. Collection	13.04%	42.60	04.63	fcloud
161	Timmy31m	17.39%	29.71	04.52	Timmy31m
162	tschoppenhorst	13.04%	41.00	04.46	tschoppenhorst
163	friedmad	8.70%	66.00	04.30	friedmad
164	Taz	13.04%	65.33	04.26	Taz
164	S.Chacon	13.04%	65.33	04.26	S.Chacon
166	Hoopesaa	17.39%	21.86	03.33	Hoopesaa
167	Happymoon	21.74%	8.38	01.46	Happymoon
168	The Buffalo Set	4.35%	66.00	01.43	beach64
169	Big Shep	4.35%	65.00	01.41	Big Shep
170	Guttrott	34.78%	3.53	01.30	Guttrott