Indian Head $5 Gold, Circulation Strikes (1908-1929) Current Finest List

Number of
Required Items

Current Finest
Possible Set Rating

67.765

In 1908 the transition was made from the long-lived $5 Liberty series (1839-1908) to the radically designed $5 Indian. Both the $5 and $2 1/2 Indian gold pieces were introduced in 1908, and both carried the incuse design, never seen before (or since) on a United States coin.

The $5 Indian series is filled with rarities. In fact, 15 of the 24 dates have a population of seven or less in MS65! Two of the 24 dates are unknown in MS65 or better, or at least uncertified. PCGS has graded well over 40,000 $5 Indians in all dates and grades, but barely 300 have qualified as MS65 or better. Key dates of the series in any mint state grade include the 1908-S, 1909-O, 1909-S, 1910-S, 1911-D, 1912-S, 1913-S, 1914-S, 1915-S, and 1929.

Current Finest

Rank	Set Name	% Complete	GPA Weighted	GPA with Top Pop Bonuses	Set Rating	User
1	HALFDOME 2022 2023 2024 2025	100.00%	65.31	65.85	65.85	LEGENDNUMIS1
2	Naples Collector	100.00%	64.22	64.24	64.24	Naples Collector
3	Deer Grove Collection	100.00%	63.94	63.96	63.96	DeerGrove
4	GT Legacy	100.00%	62.30	62.30	62.30	JerryT
5	Quiver Collection	100.00%	59.97	59.97	59.97	Quiver Collectibles
6	MDB's Indian $5	95.83%	62.57	62.57	59.45	55Baldy
7	Rafus	100.00%	58.45	58.45	58.45	Rafus
8	O'Branovich Collection	100.00%	57.85	57.85	57.85	obranovich
9	Stony Point Collection	95.83%	60.34	60.34	57.33	Kliney
10	Alzvette $5 Indian's by LDRC	95.83%	56.10	56.10	53.30	ldrc
11	Fairmont Collection - CBL Set	83.33%	63.02	63.02	51.68	Fairmont Collection
12	Ötzi	87.50%	65.49	65.87	51.38	iceman
13	Full Five Indians	87.50%	58.44	58.44	47.92	VegasRacer
14	Hansin Collection Indian Head $5 Circ. Gold 1908/29	75.00%	63.82	63.82	44.04	gold2010
15	Basileboy	70.83%	61.30	61.30	38.62	JB C&B
16	Kaw-Liga’s Wampum	54.17%	63.60	63.60	36.25	UPS Guy 20
17	JHY	70.83%	54.79	54.79	33.97	JHY
18	Sacks Collection	70.83%	57.45	57.45	31.60	rickyandnicky
19	Tom's Indian Head $5 Gold	45.83%	60.47	60.47	28.42	remm
20	pasadenaoldhouse	62.50%	52.33	52.33	28.26	[email protected]
21	rsh442	45.83%	59.81	59.81	26.32	rsh442
22	ritzfam	62.50%	62.36	62.36	26.19	ritzfam
23	wd99	62.50%	37.69	37.69	24.12	[email protected]
24	The Northridge $5 Indian Head Collection	41.67%	57.70	57.70	23.08	Morgan97
25	Daniels $5 Indian Gold Set	41.67%	59.45	59.45	19.03	wdaniels1
26	idealassets	33.33%	54.45	54.45	17.97	idealassets
27	Stony Point II	41.67%	57.60	57.60	17.28	Kliney
28	More Head for $5	50.00%	53.67	53.67	16.10	Coinage
29	Lbonser	41.67%	42.16	42.16	15.60	Lbonser
30	CMac's Indians	20.83%	48.87	48.87	14.66	cmac98
31	fishbackwoods	37.50%	59.75	59.75	14.34	fishbackwoods
32	Morgan575757	33.33%	64.39	64.39	12.24	spivey
33	The R.S.Gore Collection	37.50%	61.68	61.68	11.72	rgore1793
34	felinfoel	20.83%	49.78	49.78	11.45	felinfoel
35	rick's half dollars	25.00%	49.65	49.65	11.42	rick's half dollars
36	Deegm	29.17%	63.65	63.65	10.82	Deegm
37	The Northridge II $5 Indian Head Collection	12.50%	58.00	58.00	10.44	Morgan97
38	MADELINE	20.83%	46.71	46.71	09.81	carstand
39	CSF	25.00%	60.06	60.06	09.61	neocacher
40	Gl3nn	29.17%	63.89	63.89	08.95	Gl3nn
41	GivenToFly	12.50%	58.77	58.77	07.64	GivenToFly
42	mjplays	20.83%	56.62	56.62	07.36	mjplays
43	andex	25.00%	30.60	30.60	06.12	[email protected]
44	bbergmann	29.17%	60.20	60.20	06.02	bbergmann
45	[email protected]	12.50%	50.80	50.80	05.08	Anonymous
46	Simpson 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 10 2020	12.50%	66.43	67.29	04.71	Simpson
47	thetalpha	4.17%	58.00	58.00	04.64	[email protected]
48	7ville	16.67%	63.00	63.00	04.41	7ville
49	mygirlre1 (2)	12.50%	60.40	60.40	03.02	[email protected]
50	Dr. Cheney's $5 Indians	12.50%	54.80	54.80	02.74	sfs92530
51	Salamandermike	12.50%	56.25	56.25	02.25	Salamandermike
52	david	4.17%	64.50	64.50	01.94	[email protected]
53	makndavis	4.17%	62.00	62.00	01.24	makndavis
54	Marko's Indian $5 Gold	4.17%	63.00	63.00	00.63	msrdanov
55	mygirlre1	4.17%	62.50	62.50	00.63	[email protected]
56	JHY (2)	4.17%	61.00	61.00	00.61	JHY