Laibstain. Hugon. A beautifully toned superb gem that is well struck and matches the coin described in the Emery-Nichols catalog, and considering the limited number of coins in MS 66 and up, this example most likely is from Emery-Nichols. Unfortunately, most coins sold at the time of the Emery-Nichols Sale have either small black and white photographs in the catalog, or no photographs at all. This makes trying to match such coins very difficult. In putting this set together, a few coins have been traced back to important collections, but with no designation on the holder when first obtained. Obtaining specific pedigree information is great fun and is very rewarding to us. Occasionally one can find an expert like David Akers, David Hall, or others who can remember specific coins and link them back to a specific set or auction, and that can be a tremendous help. Only one 1903-S is graded finer at MS 68.
David Akers: The 1903-S Barber Half Dollar is a very scarce date in any mint state grade, but it can be located with only a moderate amount of difficulty in grades below Gem condition. However, Gems are very rare...
The 1903-S Half Dollar is a typical date in the series -- not particularly rare; affordable; and easy to find in most grades. In terms of production quality, two issues will vex the collector: the strike is sometimes weak on the upper right corner of the shield and on the eagle's wing in that area; and, on many examples, particularly those in high grade, roller marks can be seen on one or both sides. Roller marks arise from the planchet manufacturing process. To produce planchets, bars and strips of silver are squeezed between rollers until they reach the proper thickness. Any defects or wear lines on the rollers will transfer to the metal itself. If, during the striking process, the pressure is set too low, the transferred lines and defects will not be obliterated. Not all 1903-S Half Dollars have roller marks, and some of the best examples have them. Not unexpectedly, the coins with roller marks will often have a weaker-than-optimum strike. Given the option (assuming it is even available), collectors should choose fully-struck examples as free of roller marks as possible.
The finest 1903-S Half Dollar is the PCGS MS68 example from the Eliasberg Collection (there catalogued as a raw MS66). Collector J.M. Clapp obtained the coin directly from the San Francsico Mint in 1903.
San Francisco Mint - J.M. Clapp Collection - John H. Clapp Collection, sold intact in 1942 - Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr. Collection - Bowers & Merena 4/1997:2099, $18,700
Harold April 12/1965 - James Bennett Pryor - Bowers & Merena 1/1996:290 - Dale Friend - Heritage 1/2009:3893, $11,500
© 1999 - 2015 Collectors Universe NASDAQ: CLCT