Ron Guth: At least two examples are known that are special strikings (specimen or presentation pieces).
David Akers (1975/88): Along with the 1920-S, which is just a bit less rare, the 1921 is the premier condition rarity of the Saint-Gaudens double eagle series. More than half of the total popuation is in circulated condition, and the majority of the Mint State pieces grade only MS-60. There are some around that grade MS-61 or MS-62, but in MS-63 or higher grade this issue is all but impossible to obtain. I would estimate that only eight to 10 exist in MS-63 and only a very few exist that could reasonably be graded MS-64 or better. On my rarity scale, I could probably have rated the 1921 as R-10 (Impossible) for both MS-64 and MS-65 and not received much contradiction. Three specimens stand out above the rest (of those that I have seen) by a considerable margin. Two specimens from the George Goddard Collection were sold by Stack's in 1982. Both are true gems and are virtually identical in overall quality and appearance. One is now owned by Dr. William Crawford, the other by a prominent Eastern collector. The third super 1921 is the Eliasberg example, which is almost identical to the Goddard pieces in overall appearance but has perhaps a few more tiny marks. It grades at least MS-64 and many would grade it full gem. All three coins were undoubtedly obtained directly from the Mint in the year of issue.
The 1921 is generally sharply struck with frosty surfaces and lustre that is only average at best for the series, but a very few examples have somewhat satiny surfaces and very good lustre. (The three top quality examples mentioned above all have exceptional lustre, however, and so it is entirely possible that the somewhat lacklustre appearance of most specimens is due to their low condition and not a result of how they were made.) Color is typically very good, a light to medium, sometimes even rich, orange and greenish gold. Some specimens have tiny hairline die breaks running through the letters in LIBERTY.
Dr. Thomas Louis Comparette - George Seymour Godard - possibly Senator Hall's widow, before Godard purchased his collection - Godard Collection - Stack's “Auction ‘82” 8/1982:447, $32,000 - Superior 1/1984:1875, $57,500 - Dr. & Mrs. Steven Duckor Collection - Heritage 1/2012:4630, $747,500
Possibly Ex: Thomas Comparette to George Godard to Senator Hall - Stack's 3/1982:1471, $41,000 - Crawford Collection - Phillip H. Morse Collection - Heritage 11/2005:6644 (as PCGS MS66 05651168), $1092,500
Dr. Thomas Louis Comparette - George Godard - Senator Hall - Louis Eliasberg - Bowers & Ruddy, 10/1982:1052 - Dr. Stephen Duckor - Jay Parrino (1990) - Phillip H. Morse Collection - Heritage 11/2005:6645 (as PCGS MS65), $805,000 - Simpson Collection
Bella Collection (PCGS Set Registry)
© 1999 - 2014 Collectors Universe NASDAQ: CLCT