| Rank | Collection | % Complete | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 1 |
Omega Jim's Complete Nickel Set 1866 - Present
| 75.91% | 66.653 |
50.595
|
| 2 |
KozMc Nics
| 63.86% | 65.427 |
41.784
|
| 3 |
(deleted set)
| 58.18% | 68.535 |
39.875
|
| 4 |
ajia
| 60.91% | 64.306 |
39.168
|
| 5 |
driftwood
| 55.91% | 66.650 |
37.264
|
| 6 |
Steve's Set
| 49.09% | 67.917 |
33.341
|
| 7 |
Engram Collection US Nickels
| 32.50% | 67.161 |
21.827
|
| 8 |
Cen-Cal
| 27.73% | 65.861 |
18.261
|
| 9 |
Empty Pockets
| 25.29% | 67.636 |
17.103
|
| 10 |
GrayAnimalOld5
| 21.38% | 68.806 |
14.710
|
| 11 |
ACM
| 21.38% | 66.065 |
14.124
|
| 12 |
Joesbline
| 17.93% | 67.718 |
12.143
|
| 13 |
Neibaur Collection
| 15.86% | 67.986 |
10.784
|
| 14 |
ilovepcgs
| 15.63% | 66.353 |
10.372
|
| 15 |
(deleted set)
| 11.26% | 70.837 |
07.979
|
| 16 |
Lantern Collection
| 12.18% | 65.019 |
07.922
|
| 17 |
Bear Creek Collection
| 11.72% | 66.725 |
07.823
|
| 18 |
(deleted set)
| 10.11% | 68.682 |
06.947
|
| 19 |
(deleted set)
| 08.97% | 70.282 |
06.301
|
| 20 |
Andre Collection
| 07.82% | 70.324 |
05.497
|
| 21 |
jstapleton759
| 07.82% | 69.382 |
05.423
|
| 22 |
Magicman
| 07.13% | 67.742 |
04.828
|
| 23 |
MichaelD8577's U.S. Nickels Complete Set (1866-Present)
| 05.98% | 69.731 |
04.168
|
| 24 |
Frankel Collection
| 05.75% | 70.360 |
04.044
|
| 25 |
TAC collection
| 05.75% | 67.240 |
03.864
|
| 26 |
msettles
| 04.60% | 69.500 |
03.195
|
| 27 |
The Juno Collection
| 04.37% | 69.421 |
03.032
|
| 28 |
pfboris01
| 04.14% | 66.222 |
02.740
|
| 29 |
weldonwright
| 02.30% | 68.300 |
01.570
|
| 30 |
jmk19
| 02.07% | 66.222 |
01.370
|