| Rank | Collection | % Complete | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 1 |
Prairie Gold
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
xpnsvewno
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
fwheat
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
gjgott
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
HawkeEye
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
Lubah's American Buffalo Complete Gold Set, Proof (2006-present)
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
TheKrogerCollection
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
MarkBen
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
jddawson
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
ElHajj1
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
Uncle Trav A
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
kmgken
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
kmgken (2)
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
Hogan Collection - Proof Gold Buffalo
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
(deleted set)
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
The EFG Collection
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
MGM Collection
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
SJO Gold PR Buffalos
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
BK Spartan
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
The Twinight Collection
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 21 |
ProofModerns Proof Gold Buff Set
| 100.00% | 69.375 |
69.375
|
| 22 |
psu256
| 100.00% | 69.125 |
69.125
|
| 23 |
driftwood
| 100.00% | 69.000 |
69.000
|
| 24 |
Seventy Buffalo's
| 88.89% | 70.000 |
65.882
|
| 24 |
Prairiedoc
| 88.89% | 70.000 |
65.882
|
| 26 |
Deegm
| 87.50% | 70.000 |
61.250
|
| 26 |
cab_guy
| 87.50% | 70.000 |
61.250
|
| 26 |
Martz Collection
| 87.50% | 70.000 |
61.250
|
| 26 |
Martz Collection 2
| 87.50% | 70.000 |
61.250
|
| 30 |
Rocky Mountain High Buffalo Stampede
| 75.00% | 70.000 |
52.500
|
| 30 |
Complete Buffalo PR70 FS
| 75.00% | 70.000 |
52.500
|
| 32 |
Bear Creek Collection
| 75.00% | 70.000 |
48.125
|
| 33 |
FredJoan
| 62.50% | 69.364 |
47.688
|
| 34 |
FABG
| 62.50% | 70.000 |
43.750
|
| 34 |
xpnsvewno (2)
| 62.50% | 70.000 |
43.750
|
| 36 |
m4ctadas (3)
| 62.50% | 69.300 |
43.313
|
| 37 |
Highland
| 62.50% | 69.444 |
39.063
|
| 38 |
GBohanan
| 50.00% | 70.000 |
35.000
|
| 39 |
Saharac
| 37.50% | 70.000 |
30.625
|
| 40 |
jandhr
| 37.50% | 70.000 |
26.250
|
| 41 |
lns1
| 37.50% | 69.667 |
26.125
|
| 42 |
Alcon
| 37.50% | 69.000 |
25.875
|
| 43 |
xpnsvewno (3)
| 25.00% | 70.000 |
21.875
|
| 44 |
Georgia Proof Buffalo
| 37.50% | 69.400 |
21.688
|
| 45 |
Omega Jim's Buffalo Gold Proofs
| 25.00% | 70.000 |
17.500
|
| 45 |
(deleted set)
| 25.00% | 70.000 |
17.500
|
| 45 |
(deleted set)
| 25.00% | 70.000 |
17.500
|
| 48 |
allsho*
| 25.00% | 69.500 |
17.375
|
| 48 |
(deleted set)
| 25.00% | 69.500 |
17.375
|
| 48 |
thelondoncoincompany
| 25.00% | 69.500 |
17.375
|
| 51 |
jackalfried
| 25.00% | 69.000 |
17.250
|
| 51 |
woddie
| 25.00% | 69.000 |
17.250
|
| 51 |
Eldorado
| 25.00% | 69.000 |
17.250
|
| 54 |
fcpowell
| 12.50% | 70.000 |
08.750
|
| 54 |
(deleted set)
| 12.50% | 70.000 |
08.750
|
| 56 |
(deleted set)
| 12.50% | 69.000 |
08.625
|
