| Rank | Collection | % Complete | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 1 |
Carl Womack Buffalo Collection (Varieties)
| 100.00% | 65.613 |
65.613
|
| 2 |
Irv's Herd
| 100.00% | 61.507 |
61.507
|
| 3 |
Bill Fivaz Collection
| 95.77% | 64.219 |
61.178
|
| 4 |
Driftwood Buffalo Nickel Set
| 94.44% | 64.565 |
59.978
|
| 5 |
(deleted set)
| 83.33% | 63.064 |
48.418
|
| 6 |
Garrow King's Buffalo Nickels
| 66.67% | 59.541 |
39.369
|
| 7 |
Lantern Collection
| 69.44% | 64.688 |
36.762
|
| 8 |
PocketChange Buffalo Stampede
| 59.72% | 63.542 |
33.333
|
| 9 |
Melvin D. Souza
| 55.56% | 64.213 |
31.230
|
| 10 |
(deleted set)
| 36.11% | 64.739 |
15.566
|
| 11 |
(deleted set)
| 37.50% | 64.966 |
15.443
|
| 12 |
Larry's Major Variety Buffalos
| 27.78% | 52.052 |
13.795
|
| 13 |
Martin's Collection
| 23.61% | 57.311 |
11.587
|
| 14 |
ErasmusHall
| 25.00% | 65.596 |
09.320
|
| 15 |
Donald K. Warner
| 23.61% | 65.152 |
08.189
|
| 16 |
(deleted set)
| 18.06% | 58.478 |
07.350
|
| 17 |
(deleted set)
| 11.11% | 63.800 |
03.486
|
| 18 |
The R. S. Gore Collection
| 11.11% | 65.400 |
02.680
|