Magicman
| Item | PCGS No. | Date | Denom | Grade | Pop | Pop Higher | Owner's Comments |
| Shield Nickel, Rays (1866-1867) | | | 5C | | | | |
| Shield Nickel, No Rays (1867-1883) | | | 5C | | | | |
| Liberty Head Nickel, No "CENTS" (1883) | | 1883 | 5C | | | | |
| Liberty Nickel (1883-1913) | | | 5C | | | | |
| Buffalo Nickel, Type 1 (1913) | 3915 | 1913 | 5C | MS65 | 3238 | 2294 | |
| Buffalo Nickel, Type 2 (1913-1938) | 3971 | 1931-S | 5C | MS66 | 420 | 9 | |
| Jefferson Nickel (1938-2003) | 94207 | 1974-S | 5C | PR69DC | 3696 | 0 | |
| Jefferson Nickel, Wartime (1942-1945) | 84020 | 1943-D | 5C | MS66FS | 2483 | 304 | |
| Westward Journey Nickel (2004-2005) | | | 5C | | | | |
| Return to Monticello Nickel (2006-present) | | | 5C | | | | |
