PCGS grade. Purchased by Louis Eliasberg in 1942 from Stack's. Sold by Bowers & Merena Apr '97 price realized $121,000. Lot #1911. Pedigreed 12/17/15.
Ron Guth: The 1838-O Half Dollar was the first coin struck at the New Orleans Mint and one of the first branch mint coins of any denomination. Apparently, only 20 coins were made as Proofs. Today, less than a dozen have been traced, making this one of the most important American rarities.
The January 22-26, 1890 sale of the R. Coulton Davis collection by the New York Coin & Stamp Company (H.P. Smith and David Proskey) contained the following note for the 1838-O Half Dollar listed as Lot 655 “…sharp perfect impression: almost proof. We have seen a letter from Dr. Riddell, Superintendent N.O. Mint, 1838, which accompanied a similar Half Dollar, in which it was stated that only four Half Dollars of this date and mintage were issued, and judging from the extreme rarity, we do not doubt the truth of the statement.” The coin sold for $51.00
The finest Branch Mint Proof 1838-O Half Dollars graded by PCGS are a pair of Specimen-64s.
The finest Branch Mint Proof Cameo 1838-O Half Dollars graded by PCGS is a single Specimen-64 Cameo.
Col. E.H.R. Green - W.G. Baldenhofer Collection - Stack's 11/1955:708, $3,200 - Robert Pelletreau Collection - Stack's 3/1959:782 - Jerome L. Cohen - Lester Merkin - Q. David Bowers - Charles Jay - Stack's 10/1967:181, $14,000 - Dr. E. Yale Clarke Collection - Stack's 10/1975:253, $43,000 - Julian Leidman - NASCA “Bryan Collection” 11/1977:708 - Julian Leidman - Paramount “Auction ‘82” 8/1982:1689, $47,500 - unknown intermediary - Heritage 6/2005:6244, $632,500 - Greensboro Collection - Heritage 1/2013:5644, $734,375
H.O. Granberg Collection - William H. Woodin Collection - Waldo Newcomer Collection - B. Max Mehl - Col. E.H.R. Green Collection - Burdette G. Johnson - Maurice A. Ryan Collection - B. Max Mehl 6/1945:936 - Will W. Neil Collection - B. Max Mehl 6/1947:580 - James A. Stack Collection - Stack’s 3/1975:415 - Julian Leidman - Steve Ivy Numismatic Auctions 8/1982:2320 - Anthony Terranova - Kevin Lipton - George Vogt (Colonial Coins) - RARCOA “Auction ’84” 8/1984:1666 - David Queller Collection - Stack’s 10/2002:446, $184,000 - D. Brent Pogue Collection - Stack's/Bowers & Sotheby's 5/2016:4007, $493,500
Robert Coulton Davis Collection - New York Coin & Stamp 1/1890:655, $51 - S.H. & H. Chapmans (per Carl Carlson) - Martin Luther Beistle - Colonel E.H.R. Green - B.G. Johnson - Stack's (1942) - Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr. Collection - Bowers & Merena 4/1997:1911, $121,000 - Andrew Lustig and Don Kagin - John Albanese - Smoke Rise Collection - Heritage 1/2014:5249, $763,750 - Eugene H. Gardner Collection - Heritage 5/2015:98459, $646,250
New Orleans private collection, valued at $40 - Ferguson Haines Collection - S.H. & H. Chapman 10/1888:483, bought in by the Chapmans (per Carl Carlson) - George Bauer - S.H. & H. Chapman 2/1903:1149 - purchased by Virgil Brand for $250 (from the Chapman Brothers’ sale or privately?) - Col. E.H.R. Green (per Carl Carlson, but the window of opportunity for Green to buy coins from Brand's collection was brief, creating some doubt about this citation) - Wayte Raymond - F.C.C. Boyd Collection - Numismatic Gallery 4/1945:410, $1,600 - Eastern Collection - Stack's - F.S. Guggenheimer Collection - Stack's 1/1953:830 - Stack's 11/1957:1344, $4,000 - New Netherlands - Jerome L. Cohen - Kreisberg-Schulman 4/1967:1065 - Abner Kreisberg Mail Bid Sale 6/1970 - Stack's 8/1971:805 - Dr. George J. Oviedo Collection - Stack's 9/1983:830 - George Byers Collection - Stack's 10/2006:1097, $253,000 - offered by Rich Uhrich Coins in 12/2014 for $425,000 - Heritage 8/2015:4057, $293,750