| Rank | Collection | % Complete | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 1 |
Prairie Gold
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
gjgott
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
Mint Mint Products
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
(deleted set)
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
xpnsvewno
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
fwheat
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
Lubah's American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof (2006-present)
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
Prairiedoc
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
TheKrogerCollection
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
MarkBen
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
ElHajj1
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
MGM Collection
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
(deleted set)
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
Uncle Trav E
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
HawkeEye
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
kmgken
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 1 |
The Twinight Collection
| 100.00% | 70.000 |
70.000
|
| 18 |
Terry & Nicole
| 100.00% | 69.600 |
69.600
|
| 18 |
STK
| 100.00% | 69.600 |
69.600
|
| 20 |
FredJoan (1)
| 100.00% | 69.400 |
69.400
|
| 20 |
ProofModerns Gold Buffalo $50 Proof Set
| 100.00% | 69.400 |
69.400
|
| 22 |
FredJoan (2)
| 100.00% | 69.200 |
69.200
|
| 23 |
FredJoan (3)
| 100.00% | 69.000 |
69.000
|
| 23 |
driftwood
| 100.00% | 69.000 |
69.000
|
| 25 |
Vennekotter Collection
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
Deegm
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
FABG
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
QT921700
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
Mainor American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof (2006-present)
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
cab_guy
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
Martz Collection
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
(deleted set)
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
58.333
|
| 25 |
Martz Collection 2
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 25 |
BK Spartan
| 80.00% | 70.000 |
56.000
|
| 35 |
(deleted set)
| 80.00% | 69.750 |
55.800
|
| 35 |
easyrj
| 80.00% | 69.750 |
55.800
|
| 37 |
xpnsvewno (2)
| 80.00% | 69.500 |
55.600
|
| 38 |
The BigSarge Collection
| 60.00% | 70.000 |
42.000
|
| 38 |
floydhed
| 60.00% | 70.000 |
42.000
|
| 38 |
Ocean Lake Collection
| 60.00% | 70.000 |
42.000
|
| 38 |
Jefel's Buffaloes Madness
| 60.00% | 70.000 |
42.000
|
| 38 |
Rocky Mountain High Buffalo Stampede
| 60.00% | 70.000 |
42.000
|
| 38 |
ebaymerchant
| 60.00% | 70.000 |
42.000
|
| 44 |
phireman4
| 60.00% | 69.667 |
41.800
|
| 44 |
Highland
| 60.00% | 69.667 |
41.800
|
| 46 |
stinchfish
| 60.00% | 69.333 |
41.600
|
| 46 |
(deleted set)
| 60.00% | 69.333 |
41.600
|
| 46 |
fnord123
| 60.00% | 69.333 |
41.600
|
| 49 |
Alcon
| 60.00% | 69.000 |
41.400
|
| 50 |
Gyros - First Strike
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
The Mambro Family Collection - Proof $50 Buffalo First Strike
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
(deleted set)
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
lotto1717
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
Lake Wylie Collection
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
Bryan's PR70DCAM First Strike Set
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
The S. Trommler Jr. Collection
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
mrherron69
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
The Coleman Collection
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
KB Proof Buffalos
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
ElHajj
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
Gyros
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
Southern Eagles
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
Coinboy's Blue Label Buffalo $50 Gold Proofs
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
The WEE Collection (First Strike Proof)
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
kniky22 (2)
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
The Coleman Collection
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
xpnsvewno (3)
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
Ron C. Collection
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 50 |
(deleted set)
| 40.00% | 70.000 |
28.000
|
| 70 |
One Three's Buffalo Folly
| 40.00% | 69.500 |
27.800
|
| 70 |
montyjams
| 40.00% | 69.500 |
27.800
|
| 70 |
CMS Collection
| 40.00% | 69.500 |
27.800
|
| 70 |
Collectoroldthings
| 40.00% | 69.500 |
27.800
|
| 70 |
xpnsvewno (2)
| 40.00% | 69.500 |
27.800
|
| 70 |
halschaeffer
| 40.00% | 69.500 |
27.800
|
| 70 |
janprus
| 40.00% | 69.500 |
27.800
|
| 77 |
The Robert B. Lewis Collection
| 40.00% | 69.000 |
27.600
|
| 77 |
The Robert B. Lewis Collection II
| 40.00% | 69.000 |
27.600
|
| 77 |
Buster Howard
| 40.00% | 69.000 |
27.600
|
| 77 |
jackalfried
| 40.00% | 69.000 |
27.600
|
| 77 |
(deleted set)
| 40.00% | 69.000 |
27.600
|
| 77 |
woddie
| 40.00% | 69.000 |
27.600
|
| 83 |
Shutterlife 24k Buffalo Proofs
| 25.00% | 69.000 |
17.250
|
| 83 |
Jose's Gold Buffalo's
| 25.00% | 69.000 |
17.250
|
| 85 |
fcpowell
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
cab_guy
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
The .9999 Golden Herd
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
Bison Gold
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
Rachel Ann
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
TimPoling
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
Bryan's PR70DCAM Set
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
jimdepot
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
durian-seller
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
XXX
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
buffalo57
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
CSF
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
dnance
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 85 |
thelondoncoincompany
| 20.00% | 70.000 |
14.000
|
| 99 |
(deleted set)
| 20.00% | 69.000 |
13.800
|
| 99 |
cab_guy
| 20.00% | 69.000 |
13.800
|
| 99 |
Dr. Miller's American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof (2006-present)
| 20.00% | 69.000 |
13.800
|
| 99 |
Dr. Miller's American Buffalo $50 Gold, Proof (2006-present) 2nd Set
| 20.00% | 69.000 |
13.800
|
| 99 |
Barakka
| 20.00% | 69.000 |
13.800
|
| 99 |
Eldorado
| 20.00% | 69.000 |
13.800
|
