| Rank | Collection | % Complete | Weighted GPA | Set Rating |
| 1 |
Tom McCarroll
| 100.00% | 66.315 |
66.315
|
| 2 |
Pennsylvania Collector
| 100.00% | 66.025 |
66.025
|
| 3 |
Carl Womack Buffalo Collection
| 100.00% | 66.006 |
66.006
|
| 4 |
Donald A. Kutz
| 100.00% | 65.814 |
65.814
|
| 5 |
Larry Whitlow
| 100.00% | 65.776 |
65.776
|
| 6 |
(deleted set)
| 100.00% | 65.533 |
65.533
|
| 7 |
Jon/Lor
| 100.00% | 65.237 |
65.237
|
| 8 |
JD
| 100.00% | 65.208 |
65.208
|
| 9 |
Irv's Herd
| 100.00% | 65.025 |
65.025
|
| 10 |
cape cod buffalos
| 95.31% | 65.300 |
63.240
|
| 11 |
Bill Fivaz Collection
| 96.88% | 64.656 |
62.820
|
| 12 |
Richard Hennessy Collection
| 92.19% | 65.990 |
61.410
|
| 13 |
Carnton Collection
| 89.06% | 65.355 |
56.902
|
| 14 |
M.E. Stewart Collections
| 98.44% | 53.781 |
52.593
|
| 15 |
Bob's Buffalo Nickel Collection - Basic
| 87.50% | 63.958 |
52.256
|
| 16 |
jerry cyncynatus buffalos
| 75.00% | 64.704 |
43.476
|
| 17 |
P. Kubler Collection
| 78.13% | 61.912 |
42.186
|
| 18 |
Lantern Collection
| 76.56% | 64.675 |
42.028
|
| 19 |
steelcityman's buffs
| 57.81% | 63.678 |
34.350
|
| 20 |
East Coast Collection
| 45.31% | 65.452 |
26.016
|
| 21 |
CBH Buffalo Nickel Collection
| 51.56% | 65.575 |
23.375
|
| 22 |
CoolKarma's Buffalos
| 21.88% | 62.859 |
18.243
|
| 23 |
The Colorado Buffs
| 34.38% | 64.099 |
16.379
|
| 24 |
Montana Collection
| 35.94% | 57.893 |
15.341
|
| 25 |
ErasmusHall
| 34.38% | 65.192 |
15.013
|
| 26 |
Dave's Set
| 35.94% | 63.901 |
14.312
|
| 27 |
Dr. Paul's Tatanka Collection
| 28.13% | 65.306 |
10.095
|
| 28 |
(deleted set)
| 18.75% | 58.423 |
09.584
|
| 29 |
Donald K. Warner
| 26.56% | 65.152 |
09.454
|
| 30 |
(deleted set)
| 25.00% | 65.209 |
08.845
|
| 31 |
Garrow King's Basic Buffalo Set
| 14.06% | 63.881 |
08.464
|
| 32 |
(deleted set)
| 25.00% | 58.932 |
08.180
|
| 33 |
(deleted set)
| 18.75% | 64.611 |
07.338
|
| 34 |
(deleted set)
| 18.75% | 59.211 |
07.098
|
| 35 |
A simple Buffalo collection
| 17.19% | 65.000 |
05.741
|
| 36 |
The Milentius II Set
| 14.06% | 65.130 |
04.726
|
| 37 |
HKnJameses
| 15.63% | 65.000 |
04.716
|
| 38 |
RSD
| 12.50% | 64.333 |
03.653
|
| 39 |
The R.S.Gore Collection
| 10.94% | 65.462 |
02.685
|
