PCGS The Standard for the Rare Coin Industry
PCGS Set Registry® 82,572 Registered Sets

Cardinal Collection - 2nd

2009 2010 2011 2012
Current Statistics

GPA with Top Bonuses

GPA Weighted


Set Rating


Retired Statistics

GPA Weighted


Set Rating


About This Set:

The Mint Act of 1792 provided that the obverse of each coin must bear an image "emblematic of liberty," but how should "liberty" be portrayed? Should it be a metaphor for the freedom of time, as demonstrated by the sundial depicted on certain colonial issues, such as the Continental Dollar and Fugio cents? Perhaps a portrait of General George Washington, whose service during the Revolutionary War secured liberty for the country? Actually, quite a few different "Washington" cents were produced at that time, with that idea in mind.

Ultimately, the early Mint engravers answered that question, taking their cue from the Libertas Americana medal. Conceived and brought to fruition through the efforts of Benjamin Franklin to commemorate the Colonies' victories in the War, the Libertas Americana medal is universally agreed to be the most beautiful of all American colonial medals.

This set of Middle Date Large cents, a subset of the Cardinal Collection Large Cent Date Set, is dedicated to the beauty of the Libertas Americana medal and her offspring, all of the beautiful portraits of Liberty that graced U.S. large cents.

While nothing can quite compare with examining these amazing specimens in person, and seeing with your own eyes their beaming luster and sparkling shades of mint red and brown, the images that follow attempt to come as close as digitally possible. I hope you enjoy the display, and may you find it interesting and informative.

Cardinal Collection

Image Item PCGS # Date Denom Grade PCGS # Pop PCGS # Pop Higher Pop Pop Higher Comments
1816 36541 1816 1C MS66BN 1 343
Minted from 1816 to 1839, the "middle date" cents are all typically referred to as "Coronet Cents"; however, the portrait of Liberty did see several design modifications. Indeed, like the Classic Head cents before them, the Coronet cents had their detractors, who referred to the early Coronet designs as featuring the "obese ward boss." Perhaps, these snickering comments made their way back to the Mint, providing incentive for the design modifications. The earliest design, aptly called the "Matron Head," displays a matronly figure of liberty, mature and sophisticated. This subtype was produced from 1816 to 1829. From 1830 to 1835, the Matron Head design was gently modified to a somewhat more youthful look, with a tighter neck and more defined chin. Starting in 1835, Christian Gobrecht's artistic influences were seen throughout the full spectrum of American coinage, including a complete redesign of the Cent. The so-called Gobrecht "Head of '36" cent displays the new youthful Liberty with noticeably slimmer neck and still more defined chin, along with a total facial makeover. This design lasted from mid-1835 to mid-1837. The "Head of '38" cent came next, now displaying beaded hair cords to Liberty, in place of the previously plain cords. This design was featured from mid-1837 to early 1839. As the designs were being updated with greater speed, the Year 1839 witnessed no less than three distinctly different styles of the Coronet Cent (and the first Braided Hair Cents). 19th century coin dealer Ebenezer Locke Mason worked to sort these out, and in 1868 he described the distinguishing features of each, including two with rather colorful nicknames. The first of these colorfully-named 1839 cents features the addition of a hair curl at Liberty's forehead. Dubbed by Mason as the "Silly Head," the nickname has remained ever since. Finally, the Coronet cents experienced their last modification, exposing Liberty's shoulder between her flowing curls. Mason nicknamed this style as well, and henceforth it has been known as the "Booby Head." The collection includes each of these distinctive portraits of Liberty, including the transitional portrait varieties of each date, starting with 1816 N-7 cent (Noyes #21019).
1817 1594 1817 1C MS66BN 2 1087
N-13 Noyes #58032
1818 1600 1818 1C MS66BN 1 3278
N-10 Not in Noyes
1819 1607 1819 1C MS65RB
N-8 Not in Noyes
1820 36674 1820 1C MS66RB 1 819
N-13 Noyes #20984
1821 1622 1821 1C MS63RB 2 25
N-2 Not in Noyes
1822 36721 1822 1C MS65BN 3 46
N-4 Noyes #21532
1823 1627 1823 1C AU58BN 3 3 811
N-2 Noyes #34514. Genuine 1823 cents were recognized very early on for their rarity, leading to the production of later "restrikes" using the discarded broken dies.
1824 1637 1824 1C MS64RB 3 1 45
N-4 Noyes #35711 as MS65 "Choice - virtually flawless." Tied as CC#1 in the EAC census with the Naftzer PCGS-MS66RB specimen.
1825 36802 1825 1C MS66BN 1 27
N-8 Noyes #21467
1826 36826 1826 1C MS66BN 3 66
N-6 Noyes #21332
1827 36868 1827 1C MS66BN 1 54
N-11 Noyes #20751
1828 36886 1828 1C MS66BN 1 210
N-5 Noyes #21216
1829 36925 1829 1C MS66BN 1 27
N-8 Noyes #33719
1830 1673 1830 1C MS65RB 1 31
N-3 Noyes #21565
1831 36974 1831 1C MS65RB 1 51
N-6 Noyes #28736
1832 37010 1832 1C MS66RB 2 0 20
N-3 Noyes #28832
1833 37022 1833 1C MS66RB 1 41
N-2 Noyes #33678
1834 37037 1834 1C MS65RB 2 83
N-3 Noyes #21020
1835 37064 1835 1C MS65RB 2 82
1835 is the first of the transitional years for the middle date coronet cents. First is the "Head of 1834" portrait, represented by the N-1 cent (Noyes #56764), followed by the "Head of 1836" portrait, represented by the N-14 cent (Noyes #36392).
1836 37118 1836 1C MS66RB 1 21
N-3 Noyes #20641
1837 37162 1837 1C MS67BN 1 2111
Another transitional year for middle date cents, the year 1837 witnessed the progression from the "Head of 1836" portrait style to the "Head of 1838" portrait, represented here by the N-7 cent (Noyes #21247) and the N-10 cent (Noyes #20845).
1838 37189 1838 1C MS67BN 1 2100
N-4 Noyes #21339
1839 37247 1839 1C MS66RB 1 55
The Year 1839 was a very active one for the Mint's engravers, resulting in no less than three distinctly different styles of the Coronet Cent (and the first Braided Hair Cents). 19th century coin dealer Ebenezer Locke Mason described the distinguishing features of each, including two with rather colorful nicknames of "Silly Head" and "Booby Head." All four portrait styles are present in the collection, including the "Head of 1838" (N-3 Noyes #20596), the "Silly Head" (N-9 Noyes #20945), the "Booby Head" (N-11 Noyes #20819), and the Braided Hair "Head of 1840" (N-8, not in Noyes).