PCGS The Standard for the Rare Coin Industry
PCGS Set Registry® 82,546 Registered Sets

CoolKarma's Buffalos - 22nd

Current Statistics
Rank

22
GPA with Top Bonuses

63.344
GPA Weighted

63.344
Complete

100.00%
Set Rating

63.344

About This Set: A lovely set that I've been working on a long time. I have most of the missing coins, but not in PCGS holders. I'm still looking for a few. Someday... I've begun submitting many of the raw coins, all listed as "raw" in the description.

CoolKarma's Buffalos

Image Item PCGS # Date Denom Grade PCGS # Pop PCGS # Pop Higher Pop Pop Higher Comments
1913 Type 1 3915 1913 5C MS66 1984 665 1985665
raw, excellent, proof-like strike
1913-D Type 1 3916 1913-D 5C MS65 847 534 852535
raw, excellent strike
1913-S Type 1 3917 1913-S 5C MS65 359 187 359187
1913 Type 2 3921 1913 5C MS66 223 37 22337
Beautiful coin. Gold ringed with purple beginning to show in the center, both sides. EB
1913-D Type 2 3922 1913-D 5C MS63 298 616 298616
OGH (Old Green Holder)
1913-S Type 2 3923 1913-S 5C MS65 121 46 12146
Raw, recut profile
1914 3924 1914 5C MS66 162 38 16438
Purchased PCGS. EB
1914-D 3925 1914-D 5C MS65 179 62 17962
Well struck with nice luster
1914-S 3926 1914-S 5C MS62 191 1171 1911171
OGH, recut profile and date. CAC
1915 3927 1915 5C MS67 48 6 486
1915-D 3928 1915-D 5C MS64 259 192 259192
1915-S 3929 1915-S 5C MS64 255 169 255169
H
1916 3930 1916 5C MS66 227 35 22735
TT
1916-D 3932 1916-D 5C MS63 487 620 487620
Purchased unattributed PCGS. Appears to be proto 3HL. TT
1916-S 3933 1916-S 5C MS63 305 491 305491
Purchased unattribtued raw. Appears to be No F. Slightly weak strike
1917 3934 1917 5C MS65 316 209 316209
1917-D 3935 1917-D 5C MS64 380 191 382191
OGH
1917-S 38443 1917-S 5C MS64 3 220121
Purchased unattributed PCGS. 2F, FS-401. TV
1918 3937 1918 5C MS66 63 11 6411
1918-D 3938 1918-D 5C MS63 174 342 180370
OGH
1918-S 3940 1918-S 5C MS63 150 247 152247
H
1919 3941 1919 5C MS66 157 36 15736
H
1919-D 3942 1919-D 5C MS63 130 322 131322
1919-S 3943 1919-S 5C MS63 212 244 212244
OGH
1920 3944 1920 5C MS65 264 164 265164
CAC
1920-D 3945 1920-D 5C MS63 114 350 114350
Purchased NGC 62 -> raw. Light golden hue, nice strike for the date.
1920-S 3946 1920-S 5C MS63 139 275 140275
OGH
1921 3947 1921 5C MS66 182 40 18340
Purchased PCGS. EB
1921-S 3948 1921-S 5C MS64 215 85 21787
1923 3949 1923 5C MS63 257 1142 2571142
Raw.
1923-S 3950 1923-S 5C MS64 417 69 41769
Well-struck, nice luster underlying mellow patina
1924 3951 1924 5C MS65 231 137 231137
Purchased unattributed PCGS. Appears to be No F, die 1. HA
1924-D 3952 1924-D 5C MS63 119 538 119538
OGH
1924-S 3953 1924-S 5C MS62 32 279 32279
OGH. Great luster, good obv strike, weak reverse. TT
1925 3954 1925 5C MS66 237 41 23741
1925-D 3955 1925-D 5C MS63 214 524 215524
OGH
1925-S 3956 1925-S 5C MS62 76 528 77533
Nice. CAC.
1926 569448 1926 5C MS66 2 43478
Purchased unattributed PCGS. DDO/DDR. FS-101/801. Beginning to tone with hints of light gold and purple.
1926-D 3958 1926-D 5C MS62 215 850 215853
Raw, very weak reverse. Squashed "D".
1926-S 3959 1926-S 5C XF45 92 502 92502
Purchased Anacs XF40 -> raw. EB
1927 3960 1927 5C MS66 327 44 32744
Nice strike. Beautiful steel blue to purple with a yellow-gold ring starting to form
1927-D 3961 1927-D 5C MS64 479 98 47998
Purchased PCGS, unattributed. D/D/D rpm, not in FS or Authoritative Reference.
1927-S 3962 1927-S 5C MS64 266 45 26745
1928 3963 1928 5C MS66 222 45 22245
Soft light golden glow near the rim.
1928-D 3964 1928-D 5C MS64 1426 478 1426478
raw, nice luster and color
1928-S 3965 1928-S 5C MS64 389 99 38999
OGH,near proof-like fields
1929 3966 1929 5C MS66 203 30 20430
Purchased secure PCGS. Blazing lustre. KCV
1929-D 3967 1929-D 5C MS63 322 897 322897
Raw, semi prooflike fields, some gold toning
1929-S 3968 1929-S 5C MS66 239 19 23919
Nice strike. Soft golden rose toning.
1930 3969 1930 5C MS66 430 82 44383
1930-S 569452 1930-S 5C MS66 2 18717
Beautiful! Purchased unattributed PCGS/CAC. DDO, FS-101. ST
1931-S 3971 1931-S 5C MS66 488 40 48840
Rose toning on high points, gold beginning on obverse rim. CAC.
1934 3972 1934 5C MS66 211 38 21138
Nice strike. Steel blue with just a touch of light gold toning.
1934-D 3973 1934-D 5C MS64 1096 525 1096525
Purchased raw,unattributed. D/D, RPM-001. Proof-like mirrored fields.
1935 3974 1935 5C MS66 696 171 696171
Raw, superb ranbow toning, from gold rims to purple centers.
1935-D 3975 1935-D 5C MS65 511 228 511228
Raw, nice color, slightly weak obv strike
1935-S 3976 1935-S 5C MS66 440 67 44067
1936 3977 1936 5C MS66 1266 147 1271148
raw, excellent strike and luster
1936-D 3978 1936-D 5C MS66 768 87 78388
Purchased attributed PCGS, "Minor Variety RPM". RPM-5. Ex-Benson.
1936-S 3979 1936-S 5C MS66 698 106 699106
OGH. Slight steel blue color
1937 3980 1937 5C MS67 380 46 38046
1937-D 3981 1937-D 5C MS67 107 8 1078
Purchased attributed "Mint Error" "Repunched Mintmark" by PCGS. RPM 5. LC
1937-S 3983 1937-S 5C MS66 1832 144 1832144
Purchased unattributed PCGS. Appears to beRPM-1. S/S/S
1938-D Buffalo 3984 1938-D 5C MS67 1751 100 2092135
Gold tinged