PCGS The Standard for the Rare Coin Industry
PCGS Set Registry® 82,660 Registered Sets

The Cumberland Valley Collection - 4th

Current Statistics
Rank

4
GPA with Top Bonuses

56.423
GPA Weighted

56.423
Complete

98.48%
Set Rating

55.568

The Cumberland Valley Collection

Image Item PCGS # Date Denom Grade PCGS # Pop PCGS # Pop Higher Pop Pop Higher Comments
Draped Bust Half Cent (1800-1808) 1075 1804 1/2C AU58BN 26 27 339650
Spiked Chin. Cohen 8. Manley Die State 3.0. I have wanted to own one of these from the time that I saw it listed in my first Red Book in 1962. From the November 2014 Heritage Beverly Hills sale where it was partially described as: " A medium brown example of the famous " Spiked Chin " variety, caused when a bolt ( or some other hard object ) was struck into the obverse die. The surfaces of the present coin are unblemished and attractive.".
Classic Head Half Cent (1809-1836) 1147 1828 1/2C AU58BN 155 331 8232788
Cohen 3. Thirteen stars. Well struck with tiny traces of faded mint red. Almost certainly from the Benjamin H. Collins hoard of 1000 coins discovered circa 1894. The reverse is rotated 10 degrees. Purchased on Ebay in March 2013.
Braided Hair Half Cent (1840-1857) 1224 1851 1/2C AU58BN 136 294 7024052
Cohen 1.Part of a third 1 can be seen to the right of the last 1 in date. Purchased from J.J.Teaparty at the 2012 ANA.
Draped Bust Cent (1800-1807) 1470 1802 1C AU53BN 20 55 74350
Sheldon 237. Die crack from rim through N in UNITED to lowest left leaf through ribbons above the knot to right wreath stem. Other minor die cracks. Hard surfaces. A superb large cent. Purchased from Numismatic Financial Corporation at the 2013 FUN show. Earlier from Stack's September 1987 sale.
Classic Head Cent (1808-1814) 1543 1808 1C AU55BN 5 23 116266
Sheldon 278. Lustrous surfaces with hints of faded mint red. A superb Classic Head Cent. Purchased from Eagle Eye Rare Coins at the 2017 FUN show.
Coronet Head Cent (1816-1839) 1600 1818 1C AU58BN 101 406 8744038
Newcomb 10.A Randall hoard coin.Obverse die crack connects the inner points of the stars and the date.Still has some subdued original mint red.Purchased on Ebay in December 2010.
Braided Hair Cent (1839-1857) 1904 1854 1C MS61BN 5 386 878333
Newcomb 25. Beautiful light chocolate brown.Purchased from Doug Bird as AU-58 at the 1996 GCNE show.
Flying Eagle Cent (1856-1858) 2016 1857 1C AU58 314 2860 6186110
This is the variety with the broken wing tip. Closed E in ONE. A full sharp strike with great luster and a lot of original color. Purchased on Ebay in May 2013.
Indian Cent Cop Nic, No Shield (1859) 2052 1859 1C AU58 278 1864 2782153
CAC sticker. Purchased from the 2013 Heritage CSNS sale of the Malibou Lake collection.
Indian Cent Cop Nic (1860-1864) 2070 1864 1C AU58 205 1624 118010582
Satiny luster.Die crack from upper left wreath to top left of shield to rim.Purchased from J.J Teaparty in April 2013.
Indian Cent Bronze (1864-1899) 2187 1894 1C AU58BN 57 210 206751701
Chocolate brown.Purchased on Ebay in September 2010.
Two Cents (1864-1873) 3576 1864 2C AU58+ BN 2 1152 614460
Large motto. A very nice coin with a lot of luster and hints of faded mint red.Die crack from rim through right side of 8,in date,to shield.Purchased on Ebay in July 2011.CAC sticker.
Nickel Three Cents (1865-1889) 3749 1881 3CN AU58 112 591 136028835
Fully struck.CAC sticker.Purchased from Knightly Numismatics in March 2013.
Shield Nickel, Rays (1866-1867) 3790 1866 5C AU58 178 1360 2572199
Reverse die crack through the top of STATES OF AME down through the middle of ER and then back up through the top of ICA. S in TRUST, on the obverse, very weak because of grease in the die. Very nice luster. CAC sticker. Purchased from Kaminski Coin Company at the 2014 GNA show.
Shield Nickel, No Rays (1867-1883) 3813 1883 5C AU58 332 1822 94817962
Numerous obverse and reverse die cracks.This coin retains considerable luster, that is lacking in a lot of Shield nickels. Purchased from The Type Coin Company at the 2009 ANA.
Liberty Head Nickel, No "CENTS" (1883) 3841 1883 5C MS65 1611 525 2019784
This coin has prooflike surfaces and a lot of flash.Purchased from Angel Dee's Coins at the 2009 ANA.
Liberty Head Nickel (1883-1899) 3859 1898 5C AU58 46 558 97122215
Purchased from Crabtree Coins at the 2010 Nashville Whitman show.
Three Cent Silver, Type 1 (1851-1853) 3666 1852 3CS AU58 138 1441 3543940
Purchased from J.J. Teaparty in April 2012.
Three Cent Silver, Type 2 (1854-1858) 3670 1854 3CS AU58 50 288 2151579
Beautiful golden toning. Knob of extra 5 between bases of 85 in date. Minute die crack from star through right side of M in AMERICA to rim. A superb Type Two 3 Cent Silver. Purchased from Dave Wnuck Numismatics in February 2014.
Three Cent Silver, Type 3 (1859-1873) 3677 1859 3CS AU58 47 327 4167841
Smokey gray toning. A nice Trime. Purchased from Numismatic Classics at the 2013 BRNA show.
Draped Bust Half Dime, Large Eagle (1800-1805) 4265 1800 H10C XF40 7 25 49249
A neat little coin.Valentine 2. LM-3. The LIBEKTY variety.The reverse is rotated about 30 degrees.Purchased from J.J.Teaparty in October of 1994.
Capped Bust Half Dime (1829-1837) 4280 1833 H10C AU58 99 366 8503257
Valentine 1. LM-10. Both loops of the second S in STATES filled. Beautiful blue, green and gold album toning. Slightly prooflike. Purchased from Rich Uhrich Rare U.S. Coins at the 2014 FUN show.
Liberty Seated Half Dime, No Stars (1837-1838) 4311 1837 H10C AU58 84 511 129700
Large date. A fully struck white little jewel.Purchased in November 2008.
Liberty Seated Half Dime, No Drap (1838-1840) 4321 1840 H10C AU58+ 1 188 2857
The obverse has cobalt-blue and reddish apricot peripheral toning.The reverse has blue-gray,steel-gray and golden-rose toning throughout.Abundant luster especially on the obverse.From the Frank Phillips Collection of the Bowers and Merena 2010 Baltimore sale.
Liberty Seated Half Dime, Drapery (1840-1859) 4332 1843 H10C AU58+ 1 130 34018
Fully struck. Light golden peripheral toning. Purchased from a Heritage internet auction in August 2016.
Liberty Seated Half Dime, Arrows (1853-1855) 4356 1853 H10C AU58 186 688 3381354
Fully struck. Nice luster. Purchased from Dr. Eugene Bruder in April 2014.
Liberty Seated Half Dime, Legend (1860-1873) 4401 1872-S H10C AU58 62 573 6687685
Mintmark below wreath. Light brown and sea green toning with nice underlying luster. Purchased from the Charlotte Coin Consortium at the 2012 FUN show.
Draped Bust Dime, Large Eagle (1800-1807) 4477 1805 10C XF40 18 188 73499
JR 2. 4 Berries. Purchased at the 1994 CSNS show.
Capped Bust Dime, Large Denticles (1809-1828) 4488 1814 10C AU58 20 79 152584
JR 3.Large date.Lots of mint luster with light golden and gray toning.A very nice original coin.Obverse die crack from rim to star 8.Multiple reverse die cracks through the shield.Purchased from J.J Teaparty in May 2012.
Capped Bust Dime, Small Denticles (1828-1837) 4520 1831 10C AU58 43 153 3561308
JR-2.The D in UNITED and the second S in STATES are recut. Superb golden prooflike reflective surfaces. A scarce variety in high grade. Probably condition census or very near so. CAC. Purchased from David Kahn Rare Coins at the 2014 FUN show.
Liberty Seated Dime, No Stars (1837-1838) 4562 1837 10C AU58 17 55 69306
Small Date. Fortin 103. Splashes of blue-green toning around parts of the obverse rim. Purchased from Meridian Coins at the 2015 CSNS show.
Liberty Seated Dime, No Drapery (1838-1840) 4571 1839 10C AU55 19 147 106628
Ahwash 1.Beautiful blue and green peripheral toning.The reverse is rotated about 10 degrees.Purchased from J.J. Teaparty in February 2009.
Liberty Seated Dime, Drapery (1840-1860) 4614 1857 10C AU58 32 191 3011933
Fortin 108.Loads of luster.Light golden peripheral toning.Purchased from Heritage's 2011 Pre-ANA auction.
Liberty Seated Dime, Arrows (1853-1855) 4603 1853 10C AU58 125 559 166864
Ahwash 5. Purchased from the 2012 Heritage October Dallas sale.
Liberty Seated Dime, Legend (1860-1891) 4680 1876-CC 10C AU58 26 262 82216532
Type One reverse. Blue, green and light russet toning. Purchased from Sahara Coins in May 2015.
Liberty Seated Dime, Legend, Arrows (1873-1874) 4668 1874 10C AU58 10 204 47857
Light golden peripheral toning. Minute die crack from lower left reverse rim to wreath. Except for the 1943 Steel Cent,this is the toughest post 1840 U.S. type coin to find in PCGS 58. Purchased from J.J. Teaparty in June 2013.
Barber Dime (1892-1899) 4796 1892 10C AU58 199 1379 7037336
Fully struck.Light die cracks from 1 in date through bottom of 8 and 9 to rim below 2, from tip of bust to rim below last " A " in America and through the tops of " OF AMERI ".Purchased from J.J Teaparty in April 2012.
Twenty Cents (1875-1878) 5296 1875 20C AU58 92 229 6114162
Fully struck. Blue, green and golden peripheral toning. A premium coin. Purchased from J.J. Teaparty in May 2015.
Draped Bust Quarter, Large Eagle (1804-1807) 5315 1806/5 25C AU55 6 23 58187
1806/5. Browning 1. This obverse die was used in 1805 as Browning 4. It was softened at year's end by annealing, and overdated to 1806/5. The reverse die was previously used in 1805 as Browning 4 and was later used in 1807 as Browning 1. Broken right foot of " I " and left foot of " T " in Liberty. Broken left foot of 1 in date. Broken right foot of " I " in America on reverse. Die state II with clash marks at branch, berry and top leaves. A very nice strike with the eagle's breast feathers showing. A superb Draped Bust Quarter. CAC sticker. Purchased from Harry Laibstain Rare Coins at the 2013 ANA.
Capped Bust Quarter, Large Size (1815-1828) 38975 1825/4/(2) 25C AU58 10 27 137480
1825/4/(2) Browning 2.Reverse die cracks rim to period, arrows, final A in AMERICA to rim. Die crack from rim through left side of I in UNITED to field near eagle's wing. Separate stem to upper berry and T's showing slight split in upright just above right base. Fully struck. Light gold and gray toning atop lustrous surfaces. A superb large diameter Capped Bust Quarter. CAC sticker. Purchased from Doug Winter Numismatics in September 2013.
Capped Bust Quarter, Small Size (1831-1838) 5348 1831 25C AU58 65 200 250716
Browning 2. Small letters. Light blue peripheral toning. Fully prooflike. Very fine reverse die cracks through tops of " UNITED STATES " and top of " CA " in America through the three arrow heads. A superb coin. Purchased from J.J.Teaparty in July 2012.
Liberty Seated Quarter, No Drapery (1838-1840) 5392 1839 25C AU58 13 56 43153
Type 2 reverse with curved claws on the eagle.Sharply struck. Lustrous surfaces with light golden toning. CAC sticker. A very tough type to find in AU 58,with this being the best that I have seen. Purchased from Coast to Coast Coins in December 2014.
Liberty Seated Quarter, No Motto (1840-1865) 5454 1861 25C AU58 97 387 5473703
Sea green peripheral toning.Type II reverse.CAC sticker.Purchased from the 2012 February Heritage Long Beach auction.
Liberty Seated Quarter, Arr & Rays (1853) 5426 1853 25C AU58 124 413 135438
Fully struck.CAC sticker.Purchased from J.J.Teaparty in March 2012.
Liberty Seated Quarter, Arrows NM (1854-1855) 5432 1854 25C AU58 81 245 119392
Reverse rotated about 60 degrees.Obverse die crack from lower left field near rim,through base of rock,through arrow,through base of 1 in date.Obverse die crack from bottom of 4 in date through arrow,through tip of toe to field near rim.Purchased from Gold Coast Coin Exchange in October 2011.
Liberty Seated Quarter, With Motto (1865-1891) 5524 1891 25C AU58 105 571 68312323
Superb reflective luster with electric blue and russet toning. A very pretty coin. Purchased from Knightly Numismatics in April 2013.
Liberty Seated Quarter, Motto, Arr (1873-1874) 5491 1873 25C AU58 50 134 85889
Steel blue toning on the obverse.Beautiful blue and red peripheral toning on the reverse with a golden center.Purchased from Michael Aaron Rare Coins at the 2009 ANA.
Barber Quarter (1892-1899) 5602 1892-O 25C AU58+ 3 369 77367
Type two reverse with normal mintmark placement. DDO. Doubling on "In God We Trust ". FS -101. A very nice coin. Purchased from a Heritage internet auction in September 2016.
Draped Bust Half Dollar, Lg Eagle (1801-1807) 6071 1806 50C AU55 47 96 204368
Overton 118. Tompkins 24. Pointed 6 with stem. Obverse die state 2. Reverse die state 5. Great reflective surfaces with golden and blue-green toning. Reverse die crack from rim through " O " in OF through cloud and stars to eagle head. Reverse die crack from rim through arrows to shield and another from rim to arrows. Reverse die crack from rim above " N " in UNITED through TED through top two wing feathers through STAT to rim above " E ". Purchased from Pinnacle Rarities at the 2015 ANA show.
Capped Bust Half Dollar, Let Edge (1807-1836) 6154 1829 50C AU58 211 274 57267999
Overton 119. Fully struck with light golden toning. Semi-prooflike. Purchased from Eye Appealing Coins at the 2013 ANA.
Capped Bust Half Dollar, "50 CENTS" (1836-1837) 6176 1837 50C AU50 174 1060 2001189
JR-7a.Obverse die break from rim above 4th star through tip of bust through date ending at the 12th star.Reverse die break from 2nd "T" in "STATES" through "UNITED",eagle's wing tip and through "50 CENTS".Pretty light blue-green peripheral toning on the reverse.Much better struck than normal.A very tough type to find nice.Purchased from New Orleans Rare Coins at the 2009 TSNS show.
Capped Bust Half Dollar, "HALF DOL." (1838-1839) 6181 1839-O 50C AU55 37 60 287668
JR-1b.Die breaks through almost all stars on the obverse.Purchased at the 1993 Silver Dollar show.
Liberty Seated Half Dollar, No Drap (1839) 6230 1839 50C AU50 21 90 2293
Die break through HALF DOL. on the reverse.Purchased at the 1993 Silver Dollar show.
Liberty Seated Half Dollar, No Motto (1839-1866) 6297 1859-O 50C AU58 24 68 9644377
Light golden toning with blue-green peripheral toning and ample luster underneath. Purchased from Aurora Coin Shop at the 2013 CSNS show.
Liberty Seated Half Dollar, Arr & Ray (1853) 6275 1853 50C AU55+ 4 505 4557
Nice light golden toning.Purchased from Jack Beymer at the 1993 Silver Dollar show.
Liberty Seated Half Dollar, NM, Arr (1854-1855) 6283 1855-O 50C AU58 66 236 233676
Light golden peripheral toning on both sides with light sea green toning at the date.Purchased in March 2010.
Liberty Seated Half Dollar, Motto (1866-1891) 6354 1876-S 50C AU58 30 157 73311086
Fully struck.Mostly gray toning on the obverse.Beautiful sea green and golden toning with underlying luster on the reverse.Purchased from Heritage's 2010 February Long Beach sale.
Liberty Seated Half Dollar, Mot, Arr (1873-1874) 6346 1874 50C AU58 43 195 106868
Fully struck. Minute die crack on reverse through the tops of STATE. Another minute die crack from left wing of eagle through leaf tips through HALF. Purchased from the 2016 Heritage FUN auction.
Barber Half Dollar (1892-1899) 6461 1892 50C AU58 182 888 7916181
Very nice luster. Light golden toning on the obverse. White reverse. Purchased from David Kahn Rare Coins in December 2013.
Bust Dollar, Large Eagle (1800-1804) 6887 1800 $1 XF40 149 262 4481030
B-17. BB-196. Die State IV. Twelve Arrows. Superb surfaces with light blue peripheral toning. Purchased from Mid-American Rare Coin Galleries at the 2014 ANA.
Liberty Seated Dollar, No Motto (1840-1865) 6932 1846 $1 AU58 59 88 8094302
Light golden toning with semi-prooflike surfaces. Die crack through tops of " STATES ". CAC sticker. Purchased from Eye Appealing Coins at the 2017 FUN Show.
Liberty Seated Dollar, With Motto (1866-1873) 6966 1871 $1 AU58 49 199 2872939
Prooflike,especially on the reverse.Purchased from Don Rinkor Rare Coins at the 2010 ANA.
Liberty Seated Dollar, Gob NS Obv (1836) 11225 1836 $1 PR55 32 134 49273
Original coin alignment. One of my favorite coins.Beautiful light blue peripheral toning.Purchased from Jonathan Kern at the 1994 CSNS show.
Liberty Seated Dollar, Gob ST Obv (1838-1839) $1
Trade Dollar (1873-1885) 7048 1878-S T$1 AU58 180 531 135010035
Light golden toning with a few touches of blue-green toning at the obverse rims.Prooflike,especially on the reverse.This is the variety with the medium filled mintmark.Purchased from Hallmark Rare Coins at the 2012 GNA show.
Morgan Dollar (1878-1899) 7130 1881-S $1 MS66 13795 2930 7509217415
Beautiful blue,green,violet and gold toning.Great reflectivity in the fields.Purchased at the 2009 FUN show.