Liberty Nickels Basic Set, Circulation Strikes (1883-1912) All-Time Finest List

Number of
Required Items
33
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
68.279

This set is only the second issue of nickel coinage (with a five cent value) as the "nickel" wasn't introduced until 1866. The Liberty nickel series includes the famed 1883 "No Cents" issue, the rare 1885, and the first mintmarked nickels that were issued in 1912 in Denver and San Francisco. Historic, fun and affordable for most collectors.

All-Time Finest (All Eras)

Rank Set Name % Complete GPA Weighted GPA with Top
Pop Bonuses
Set Rating User
1 D. L. Hansen Liberty Nickels (1883-1912) 100.00% 66.93 67.80 67.80
DLH
2 FORSYTHEG 2019 2020 100.00% 66.89 R 67.69 67.69
3 Greenbrier River Collection 2013 2014 2016 2017 2018 100.00% 66.85 R 67.52 67.52
tcc
4 Diana’s Liberty Nickels 100.00% 66.71 67.15 67.15
DLH
5 grandpas dream 100.00% 66.65 R 66.99 66.99
6 Rafferty Collection 2015 100.00% 66.54 R 66.91 66.91
7 The Land Of Smiles Collection 100.00% 66.31 R 66.56 66.56
8 Ali 2011 2012 100.00% 66.38 R 66.48 66.48
9 San Diego Collection 100.00% 66.35 66.41 66.41
10 Carnton Collection 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 100.00% 66.15 R 66.24 66.24
11 Dale Friend 100.00% 66.02 R 66.09 66.09
12 Club 33 100.00% 66.04 66.06 66.06
12 Amy’s Nickels Collection 100.00% 66.04 66.06 66.06
DLH
14 Baxi 2005 100.00% 65.95 R 65.95 65.95
14 Great Plains Enterprises 100.00% 65.95 R 65.95 65.95
GPE
16 JM Collection 100.00% 65.78 R 65.80 65.80
17 PacificCollection 100.00% 65.77 R 65.77 65.77
18 LA liberty nickels basic ms 100.00% 65.66 65.66 65.66
19 Liberty Nickel Collector Society 100.00% 65.61 65.61 65.61
20 JReevesTx 100.00% 65.43 65.43 65.43
21 Louis Eliasberg 100.00% 65.35 R 65.41 65.41
22 Kensey Collection 100.00% 65.34 R 65.34 65.34
23 Liberty Collection 100.00% 65.29 65.29 65.29
24 O'Brien Liberty Collection 100.00% 65.25 R 65.25 65.25
25 Driftwood Liberty Head Five Cent Nickel mint set 100.00% 65.18 65.18 65.18
26 Frank Thomas 100.00% 65.12 R 65.12 65.12
27 Gregulator 100.00% 65.00 65.00 65.00
27 Kitty Hawk Collection 100.00% 65.00 R 65.00 65.00
27 laxdive 100.00% 65.00 65.00 65.00
30 Tim Schmitz Collection -- Liberty Nickels 100.00% 64.64 64.64 64.64
31 glenncrossland 100.00% 64.47 64.47 64.47
32 KCV Lady Liberty 96.97% 66.35 66.42 64.32
33 Martin's Collection 100.00% 64.26 R 64.26 64.26
34 MnS Joint Venture Liberty Nickels 100.00% 64.11 R 64.11 64.11
35 CCcoiner 100.00% 64.06 64.06 64.06
36 nolow999 100.00% 64.05 64.05 64.05
37 RGR V Nickel Set 100.00% 64.03 R 64.03 64.03
38 Vargas V's 100.00% 64.00 64.00 64.00
38 chugum 100.00% 64.00 64.00 64.00
38 PEV_MS64 100.00% 64.00 R 64.00 64.00
38 Don's Indians 100.00% 64.00 64.00 64.00
42 The Liberty Nickel Collector Society Set 100.00% 63.97 R 63.97 63.97
43 Robinette Collection 100.00% 63.84 63.84 63.84
44 gmsimon 100.00% 63.82 R 63.82 63.82
45 Ernie Marquez - Liberty Nickels 100.00% 63.58 63.58 63.58
46 The Greenbrier River Collection 96.97% 65.45 65.64 63.56
tcc
47 Dalzell's Liberty Nickel Collection 100.00% 63.46 R 63.46 63.46
48 Great Basin Collection 100.00% 63.33 63.33 63.33
49 Typetone Mint State Liberty Nickel Set 96.97% 65.34 R 65.34 63.27
50 Glawe Collection 96.97% 65.02 R 65.02 62.97
51 The DS Collection 100.00% 62.94 62.94 62.94
52 JeffRM Liberty 5C 100.00% 62.52 62.52 62.52
53 BigBrushy-120 100.00% 61.94 61.94 61.94
54 Michael F. Hayes - The Ginjamax Collection 100.00% 61.89 R 61.89 61.89
55 Popaws Liberty Nickels 100.00% 61.71 61.71 61.71
56 lostmountainman 100.00% 61.07 61.07 61.07
57 Gib's Nickels 100.00% 60.97 60.97 60.97
58 Ernie Marquez - Liberty Nickels "Second String" 100.00% 60.42 60.42 60.42
59 Omega Jim Liberty Nickels 93.94% 65.08 65.08 59.60
60 In "Liberty" Color 96.97% 63.77 63.77 59.07
61 The Liberty Nickel Collector Society AU-58 Set 100.00% 58.00 58.00 58.00
62 George's Legacy 100.00% 57.97 R 57.97 57.97
63 Tim Schmitz 90.91% 63.29 R 63.29 57.96
64 rksangercollectibles 100.00% 57.65 57.65 57.65
65 [email protected] 100.00% 57.08 R 57.08 57.08
66 1913oneday 90.91% 63.00 63.00 55.71
67 Runnin_Texan 90.91% 64.86 64.86 55.31
68 grandma liberty head nickels 100.00% 52.54 52.54 52.54
69 long3218 81.82% 63.42 63.42 50.07
70 remumc 60.61% 65.47 65.58 45.56
71 JReevesTx-2 75.76% 63.06 63.06 45.14
72 The Kaye Collection 90.91% 49.52 49.52 43.79
73 The Fleenor Collection 81.82% 60.17 60.17 43.71
74 KozMc V'S 84.85% 52.40 52.40 39.72
75 Jesh 66.67% 65.86 65.89 38.84
76 wcwinters 66.67% 65.31 65.31 37.13
77 The Durdik Family Trust Liberty Nickels Collection 69.70% 56.58 56.58 36.93
78 Lake Superior Collection of Liberty Nickels 63.64% 64.00 64.00 36.38
79 Lindy's Libertys 63.64% 64.21 64.21 35.15
80 Pushing-49 57.58% 63.00 63.00 35.15
81 grandmas liberty nickels II 72.73% 49.61 49.61 34.46
82 Lion 63.64% 65.67 65.67 33.87
83 shsusa - Liberty 5C Basic Set, Circ 1883-1912 72.73% 47.30 47.30 33.36
84 mperikly 51.52% 63.37 63.37 30.68
85 tvshockley 54.55% 65.00 65.00 28.05
86 thecandyman 51.52% 63.21 63.21 27.95
87 LNCS 54.55% 51.45 51.45 26.54
88 Pursuit of Liberty - Liberty Nickels 45.45% 61.22 61.22 26.42
89 Stillwater Mountain Collection YN 48.48% 65.42 65.42 26.17
90 gkohr 54.55% 57.28 57.28 25.93
91 goofydog 48.48% 64.59 64.59 25.16
92 Dsessom PQ MS64 Liberty Nickels 39.39% 63.94 63.94 24.23
93 Liberty Biberty 45.45% 64.88 64.88 22.54
94 rgdjr's Liberty Nickel Basic Circulation Set (AU) 45.45% 56.86 56.86 22.15
95 The Wood Collection 42.42% 65.48 65.48 22.06
96 grandmas liberty head nickels III 48.48% 44.85 44.85 21.72
97 gthorn 4549 Liberty 5¢ UPDATED 45.45% 63.13 63.13 21.26
98 The Howe Collection 2002 2003 2004 33.33% 66.02 66.02 20.15
99 Bucephalus 36.36% 64.00 64.00 18.86
100 Crystal World 33.33% 64.63 64.63 18.37
101 McInroe V's 36.36% 66.08 66.16 17.41
102 Mojavewanderer 33.33% 63.63 63.63 16.07
103 Miss Coco Puff's Liberty Nickel Basic Set, Circulation Strikes 63.64% 26.73 26.73 15.76
104 Spare Change YN 18.18% 63.83 63.83 15.45
105 Liberty Nickel Set 18.18% 55.00 55.00 14.47
106 gembu 24.24% 64.52 64.52 14.26
107 Nlkflyn Liberty Nickel Set UPDATED 27.27% 63.24 63.24 13.98
108 Cen-Cal 24.24% 62.60 62.60 13.18
109 Cuyuna 18.18% 64.39 64.39 12.20
110 Bear Creek Collection 27.27% 64.06 64.06 12.14
111 Hugh's Liberty Nickel Collection 18.18% 63.00 63.00 11.94
112 Liberty Nickels - r5 30.30% 38.93 38.93 11.88
113 Miguel's 24.24% 33.44 33.44 11.26
114 ajia 24.24% 62.63 62.63 10.55
115 BKs V Nickels 18.18% 64.80 64.80 10.23
BKs
116 rsh442 18.18% 64.00 64.00 09.43
117 grandmas liberty head nickels IV 24.24% 44.20 44.20 09.31
118 Golden Gate Collection 18.18% 64.31 64.31 08.80
119 Foresthills Liberty Nickels 15.15% 65.33 65.33 08.25
120 Liberty Nickels 18.18% 64.50 64.50 08.15
121 emptypockets 18.18% 64.17 64.17 08.11
122 blake.j.lanning 15.15% 63.17 63.17 07.98
123 Farrington Liberty Nickels 18.18% 38.58 38.58 07.72
124 JRS Collection 18.18% 64.09 64.09 07.42
125 Runblankenship 15.15% 63.45 63.45 07.35
126 Vinny Kid 57.58% 13.67 13.67 07.34
127 B. M. SPINDLER COLLECTION 15.15% 62.27 62.27 07.21
128 wprehm 18.18% 24.36 24.36 07.18
129 Robert N Lockey 15.15% 65.30 65.30 06.87
130 Leinieboy 15.15% 63.00 63.00 06.63
131 Glenn Family Collection 12.12% 58.80 58.80 06.19
132 Sixmillion 9.09% 63.00 63.00 05.31
133 Graysonbutler406 12.12% 64.14 64.14 04.73
134 Wyoming Liberty Nickels 12.12% 17.17 17.17 04.16
135 Circulation V Nickels 9.09% 64.00 64.00 03.37
136 Eye of the Scroll 12.12% 17.28 17.28 03.27
137 Numerius Negidius 9.09% 27.91 27.91 03.23
138 Madams102 6.06% 55.60 55.60 02.93
139 jettatart 12.12% 17.19 17.19 02.89
140 Ethan 6.06% 64.50 64.50 02.72
141 Coin_Ranger - Liberty Nickels 6.06% 27.33 27.33 02.59
142 TigersFan 12.12% 10.81 10.81 01.82
143 Jkoehn7 6.06% 21.86 21.86 01.61
144 CoinGuy1859 3.03% 63.00 63.00 01.33
144 mlishman NEW 3.03% 63.00 63.00 01.33
146 Kenhedges 9.09% 5.84 5.84 01.17
147 rushmore98 3.03% 3.00 3.00 00.19