Perfection 2

Current
Rank
4
Set
Complete
100.00%
Set
Rating
67.813
GPA with
Top Bonuses
67.813
GPA
Weighted
67.754
%DCAM
0.00%

Retired Statistics 1/7/2016

Rank
4
GPA Weighted
67.820
Complete
100.00%
Set Rating
67.820
About This Set: Complete CAC set except for one coin which I will soon replace.
See MS Indian set for more thoughts!
I listed this because I am done improving it. The new PCGS scoring system that gives extra points to coins that are top pops makes it impossible for lower sets, even if great, to compete. So a lower set can have higher average coins but a lower score. I have three sets where this applies.
I cannot see the logic of giving more points to a set when none of the coins were improved.

In my opinion this set of the 4th set of all time.
The ESM top set is active so I cannot tell its score before the extra pop points. However it has 25 top pop coins in it that received bonus points.

The retired Bender set received .66 extra points and the Palm Beach set 29 extra.

This set was very difficult to complete as CAC is extremely tough on copper and many of the higher grades are pop 0. For the love of competition I challenge ESM to only use top of the grading scale CAC coins.
I love Proof Indians and have enjoyed building this set.

Image Item PCGS # Date Denom Grade PCGS # Pop PCGS # Pop Higher Pop Pop Higher Comments
1859 2247 1859 1C PR67 1 0 122
1860 2253 1860 1C PR66 19 0 194
1861 2256 1861 1C PR65+ 2 4 29
1862 82259 1862 1C PR67CAM 5 0 54
1863 82262 1863 1C PR66CAM 12 2 123
1864 Copper Nickel 82265 1864 1C PR65+ CAM 1 12 121
1864 Bronze 2277 1864 1C PR67RB 2 0 238
1865 82284 1865 1C PR64+ CAM 1 4 14
1866 82287 1866 1C PR65+ CAM 1 4 14
1867 82290 1867 1C PR65CAM 8 3 83
1868 82293 1868 1C PR66CAM 4 0 41
1869 2296 1869 1C PR66RD 3 0 317
1870 82299 1870 1C PR66CAM 4 0 40
1871 82302 1871 1C PR65CAM 2 1 21
1872 2305 1872 1C PR66RD 6 0 62
1873 2308 1873 1C PR65RD 33 5 3312
1874 82311 1874 1C PR65CAM 3 2 32
1875 2314 1875 1C PR65RD 15 3 1513
1876 2317 1876 1C PR66RD 11 0 1115
1877 2320 1877 1C PR66RD 11 2 1112
1878 82323 1878 1C PR66CAM 8 0 80
1879 2326 1879 1C PR67RD 9 0 95
1880 82329 1880 1C PR66CAM 6 3 63
1881 2332 1881 1C PR66+ RD 1 4 116
1882 2335 1882 1C PR65RD 21 22 2124
1883 2336 1883 1C PR67BN 25 5 25677
1884 82341 1884 1C PR66CAM 3 1 31
1885 2342 1885 1C PR67+ BN 5 0 5457
1886 2347 1886 1C PR65RD 20 15 2218
1887 2350 1887 1C PR64RD 13 13 1315
1888 2353 1888 1C PR65+ RD 0 3 00
1889 2356 1889 1C PR65RD 17 9 1710
1890 2358 1890 1C PR65+ RB 1 11 194
1891 2362 1891 1C PR65RD 14 4 1414
1892 2365 1892 1C PR67RD 2 0 216
1893 2368 1893 1C PR65RD 29 10 2918
1894 82371 1894 1C PR66CAM 2 1 22
1895 82374 1895 1C PR65CAM 6 1 61
1896 2377 1896 1C PR65+ RD 1 5 112
1897 2380 1897 1C PR66RD 6 3 616
1898 82383 1898 1C PR66CAM 4 5 46
1899 2386 1899 1C PR67RD 10 0 107
1900 2389 1900 1C PR66RD 18 8 1814
1901 2392 1901 1C PR66RD 28 9 2812
1902 82395 1902 1C PR67CAM 2 0 20
1903 2398 1903 1C PR67RD 11 2 116
1904 82401 1904 1C PR66CAM 3 0 30
1905 2404 1905 1C PR66RD 16 4 1612
1906 2406 1906 1C PR67RB 2 0 298
1907 2410 1907 1C PR66RD 18 3 186
1908 82413 1908 1C PR66CAM 7 0 70
1909 Indian 2416 1909 1C PR65RD 30 22 3036