Five Cent Type Set, Proof (1866-present) All-Time Finest List
Number of
Required Items
10
Required Items
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
69.409
Possible Set Rating
Since the nickel did not begin until after the mint began selling proof coins to the public, the extreme difficulties surrounding completing a Proof denomination set do not come into play here. However that doesn't mean that all the coins in this set are "easy." The With Rays Shield Nickel (1866-67) and the 1913 Type One Buffalo may both require a bit of patience and four figures to acquire a nice example.
Notes: This set has bonuses. Please see the Set Composition for a listing.
All-Time Finest (All Eras)
| Rank | Set Name | % Complete | GPA Weighted | Set Rating | User | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gavin's College Fund 2022 2023 2024 2025 | 100.00% | 69.16 | 69.16 | ||
| 2 | Corum Collection 2021 | 100.00% | 69.02 | 69.02 | ||
| 3 | Black Cat - Five Cent Type Set, Proof (1866-present) | 100.00% | R 68.95 | 68.95 | ||
| 4 | D. L. Hansen Five Cent Type Set, Proof (1866-present) 2020 | 100.00% | R 68.75 | 68.75 | ||
| 5 | Trzaska Collection 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 | 100.00% | R 68.55 | 68.55 | ||
| 6 | winesteven - 7 Coins w/CAC | 100.00% | 68.14 | 68.14 | ||
| 7 | KCV Nickel Proofs | 100.00% | R 67.75 | 67.75 | ||
| 8 | ScoutDogCoins CB | 100.00% | 67.48 | 67.48 | ||
| 9 | Terry's Proof Nickels | 100.00% | R 66.68 | 66.68 | ||
| 10 | lostmountainman | 100.00% | 66.18 | 66.18 | ||
| 11 | mikeg747 | 90.00% | 67.90 | 64.82 | ||
| 12 | tgs8695 | 80.00% | 66.70 | 60.64 | ||
| 13 | Typetone | 70.00% | 67.50 | 58.30 | ||
| 14 | seasonticketholder1999 | 80.00% | 65.73 | 44.82 | ||
| 15 | JBB Five Proof Carry On Wayward Son O' Luv | 80.00% | 67.43 | 42.91 | ||
| 16 | Hansin Collection 5 Cent Proof Type Set 1966/Present | 60.00% | 67.00 | 42.64 | ||
| 17 | Plaza Mayor | 80.00% | 66.79 | 42.50 | ||
| 18 | friedmad | 70.00% | 65.91 | 32.95 | ||
| 19 | school-man | 60.00% | 67.10 | 30.50 | ||
| 20 | O’Brien/Hutton Collection | 50.00% | 66.30 | 30.14 | ||
| 21 | Cedar City Five Cent Type Set, Proof (1866-present) | 60.00% | 67.78 | 27.73 | ||
| 22 | Greenbrier River Collection | 50.00% | 69.38 | 25.23 | ||
| 23 | The Baughman Collection | 50.00% | 69.06 | 25.11 | ||
| 24 | michaelsgems | 50.00% | 67.75 | 24.64 | ||
| 25 | Buddio | 50.00% | 68.00 | 21.64 | ||
| 26 | BowerCollection | 50.00% | 67.86 | 21.59 | ||
| 27 | Need 5 to Finish the 5’s | 50.00% | 67.71 | 21.55 | ||
| 27 | Tyler Hutton | 50.00% | 67.71 | 21.55 | ||
| 29 | CoinGuy1859 | 30.00% | 67.00 | 18.27 | ||
| 30 | Aspie-Rocco Nickel Proof Type | 40.00% | 70.00 | 15.91 | ||
| 30 | Green Oak Collection | 40.00% | 70.00 | 15.91 | ||
| 32 | swharris | 40.00% | 69.80 | 15.86 | ||
| 33 | 1 The RJ | 40.00% | 69.00 | 15.68 | ||
| 33 | Hawks7 | 40.00% | 69.00 | 15.68 | ||
| 35 | Lisa | 40.00% | 68.60 | 15.59 | ||
| 35 | J Lindquist | 40.00% | 68.60 | 15.59 | ||
| 37 | njf | 40.00% | 68.20 | 15.50 | ||
| 37 | ja29379 | 40.00% | 68.20 | 15.50 | ||
| 39 | jlzappin | 30.00% | 69.00 | 12.55 | ||
| 40 | zorknapp | 30.00% | 67.75 | 12.32 | ||
| 40 | Cheryl | 30.00% | 67.75 | 12.32 | ||
| 42 | [email protected] NEW | 20.00% | 66.00 | 12.00 | ||
| 43 | talk2thephin13 | 30.00% | 65.50 | 11.91 | ||
| 44 | tony595973 | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | Five Cent Proof Type Set - Cr2153 | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | Type Set: Five Cents Proof (1866- ) | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | Pippy361 | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | Rick Jung | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | Timmy31m | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | CosmoZ | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | mlishman | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | [email protected] | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | BillW804 | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | Neibaur Family Collection II | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | [email protected] | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | ArkieTrader | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 44 | Ohio850 | 30.00% | 72.00 | 09.82 | ||
| 58 | t.herrick | 30.00% | 71.67 | 09.77 | ||
| 58 | Vinny Kid | 30.00% | 71.67 | 09.77 | ||
| 58 | yountfan74 | 30.00% | 71.67 | 09.77 | ||
| 58 | BigTrapper | 30.00% | 71.67 | 09.77 | ||
| 58 | fny007 | 30.00% | 71.67 | 09.77 | ||
| 58 | jayrayballard | 30.00% | 71.67 | 09.77 | ||
| 64 | mthomson | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | bopiy | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | BigTrapper (2) | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | Never Forget | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | Danegeld5 | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | Willbblank | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | [email protected] | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | Dave SR Collection | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 64 | Benchan | 30.00% | 71.33 | 09.73 | ||
| 73 | Bear Creek Collection | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | SWhitehurst | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | Kat | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | Rdmfsl | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | rabideau | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | shorn2010 | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | Polarbear80 | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | moneycollector | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | coin.hunter | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | pat4president1996 YN | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | 4thbook | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | [email protected] | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | kiser159 | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | JrBaty | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | Ryan | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 73 | [email protected] | 30.00% | 71.00 | 09.68 | ||
| 89 | ApexCollecting.com | 30.00% | 70.67 | 09.64 | ||
| 90 | RoadRunner60 | 20.00% | 69.00 | 09.41 | ||
| 91 | Driftedtadpole1 | 20.00% | 67.33 | 09.18 | ||
| 92 | mcarskaddon | 20.00% | 66.50 | 09.07 | ||
| 93 | S.Basil Sabet Collection | 20.00% | 72.00 | 06.55 | ||
| 93 | ede1964 | 20.00% | 72.00 | 06.55 | ||
| 95 | cowboy2231 | 20.00% | 71.50 | 06.50 | ||
| 95 | mwyneski | 20.00% | 71.50 | 06.50 | ||
| 95 | Xtremefun30 | 20.00% | 71.50 | 06.50 | ||
| 95 | dpetty | 20.00% | 71.50 | 06.50 | ||
| 99 | jaimehoxford | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Spencer Collection | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | JonD. | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Bill Betz | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | BingoBrian | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | bstaboleski | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | dpatrick1966 | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Csoutlaw | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | cszody | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Priceless Treasurable | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | US 5 Cent Type Set, Proof (1866-present) | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | showmeyourkitties Five Cent Type Set, Proof (1866-present) | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Coreyp08 | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Tigersbooks | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | [email protected] | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | [email protected] | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | JamieHarbour | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | [email protected] | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Bleumorpho | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | VAL1632199 | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | Snovacc | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 99 | [email protected] | 20.00% | 71.00 | 06.45 | ||
| 121 | DCB | 20.00% | 70.50 | 06.41 | ||
| 122 | markrovelli | 20.00% | 70.00 | 06.36 | ||
| 123 | Big Shep | 20.00% | 69.50 | 06.32 | ||
| 124 | HortonTrust | 20.00% | 69.00 | 06.27 | ||
| 124 | DCB (2) | 20.00% | 69.00 | 06.27 | ||
| 126 | Dcreagh81 | 20.00% | 67.50 | 06.14 | ||
| 127 | SilverSiberian | 10.00% | 64.00 | 05.82 | ||
| 128 | Bella Nickels | 10.00% | 72.00 | 03.27 | ||
| 128 | detail67 | 10.00% | 72.00 | 03.27 | ||
| 128 | KALINA-COINS - USA - FIVE CENT TYPE SET, PROOF (1866-PRESENT) | 10.00% | 72.00 | 03.27 | ||
| 128 | randymassey | 10.00% | 72.00 | 03.27 | ||
| 128 | Z16autocross | 10.00% | 72.00 | 03.27 | ||
| 128 | Cole_to_the_Max | 10.00% | 72.00 | 03.27 | ||
| 128 | Sean9rw84 | 10.00% | 72.00 | 03.27 | ||
| 135 | Untouchdb1 | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | maqz99 | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | GunPlayInk | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | 7ville | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | Thomas Paine 1776 | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | LaneCorder | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | Jmbrandt22 | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | J.Ryan | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | TOMDUNN | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | chanceduncan | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | creek | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | JGabriel | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | [email protected] | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | [email protected] | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | [email protected] | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | Jbrodsky28 | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | CSM29403 | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | SilverDawg82 | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 135 | VAL1632199 (2) | 10.00% | 71.00 | 03.23 | ||
| 154 | The Bray Collection | 10.00% | 70.00 | 03.18 | ||
| 154 | [email protected] | 10.00% | 70.00 | 03.18 | ||
| 156 | slydog | 10.00% | 68.00 | 03.09 | ||
| 156 | Bobatnip Five Cent Type Set, Proof | 10.00% | 68.00 | 03.09 | ||
| 158 | Cooldude122 | 10.00% | 67.00 | 03.05 | ||
| 158 | Rich | 10.00% | 67.00 | 03.05 | ||
| 158 | CBarrentine | 10.00% | 67.00 | 03.05 | ||
| 158 | [email protected] | 10.00% | 67.00 | 03.05 | ||
| 158 | TheArmasCollection | 10.00% | 67.00 | 03.05 |