1936-Present Proof Set All-Time Finest List
Number of
Required Items
897
Required Items
Current Finest
Possible Set Rating
71.039
Possible Set Rating
To the advanced numismatist, the "modern" Proof set era really began in 1936 when, after a twenty year hiatus, the mint again began producing proof coins for collectors. This massive 658-piece set covers the entire panorama of United States Proof Coinage for the past 80 years, and encompasses the memories of nearly everyone alive today. From Buffalo Nickels, Mercury Dimes and Walkers, to the "American the Beautiful" and Native American & Presidential Dollars, this set has them all! As one might expect, the toughest coins will be the 1936-1942 pre-war issues, and finding gem examples of these will really result in a top notch set. For the modern proof coin aficianado, this ranks as the ultimate Set Registry undertaking.
Notes: This set has bonuses. Please see the Set Composition for a listing.
All-Time Finest (All Eras)
| Rank | Set Name | % Complete | GPA Weighted | GPA with Top Pop Bonuses |
Set Rating | User | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ErasmusHall 2010 2011 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 | 99.78% | 69.55 | 70.15 | 70.05 | ||
| 2 | psc | 100.00% | 69.02 | R 69.49 | 69.49 | ||
| 3 | D. L. Hansen 1936-Present Proof Set 2019 2020 | 97.58% | 69.62 | R 70.22 | 68.73 | ||
| 4 | Andy Hansen | 98.91% | 68.97 | R 69.50 | 68.55 | ||
| 5 | O’Brien/Hutton Collection | 99.87% | 68.12 | R 68.50 | 68.45 | ||
| 6 | lostmountainman | 92.63% | 68.96 | R 69.47 | 66.17 | ||
| 7 | The Hoeh Set | 94.20% | 68.97 | 69.50 | 65.25 | ||
| 8 | school-man | 90.75% | 68.15 | 68.28 | 63.62 | ||
| 9 | drbob999 | 95.76% | 68.92 | 69.48 | 61.79 | ||
| 10 | Chris Heeren Collection | 91.86% | 68.64 | 69.11 | 56.93 | ||
| 11 | Derek's 1936-Present Proof Set | 92.75% | 69.07 | 69.69 | 56.10 | ||
| 12 | Extreme Hoarders: Buried Alive | 92.20% | 68.37 | R 68.39 | 54.26 | ||
| 13 | Jim Claxton | 93.95% | 68.88 | R 69.34 | 54.06 | ||
| 14 | The MKJ Collection 2012 | 65.33% | 69.17 | R 69.60 | 53.98 | ||
| 15 | Ozarko Collection | 88.29% | 68.86 | 69.42 | 53.19 | ||
| 16 | R.Wudi Proofs UPDATED | 66.67% | 67.85 | 67.86 | 50.77 | ||
| 17 | pscovey 2009 | 55.41% | 68.43 | R 68.66 | 48.85 | ||
| 18 | The Waltz Collection | 60.76% | 67.17 | R 67.20 | 46.85 | ||
| 19 | Txosburn | 86.18% | 68.76 | 69.07 | 46.56 | ||
| 20 | JonJet | 90.88% | 69.60 | R 70.34 | 45.80 | ||
| 21 | RayB | 89.74% | 69.61 | 70.43 | 45.55 | ||
| 22 | TMKRunner Proof 36+ | 56.86% | 68.55 | 68.61 | 43.34 | ||
| 23 | mikea | 62.99% | 68.43 | 68.87 | 42.96 | ||
| 24 | Cedar City 1936-Present Proof Set | 80.49% | 69.66 | 70.47 | 40.66 | ||
| 25 | ajia | 53.29% | 67.86 | 67.86 | 38.72 | ||
| 26 | QuarterMan | 59.20% | 68.26 | 68.37 | 37.09 | ||
| 27 | DRMs 1936-Present Proof Set | 63.66% | 69.33 | 69.88 | 36.90 | ||
| 28 | jdoffer | 59.09% | 67.88 | 67.88 | 35.75 | ||
| 29 | Wacondah | 57.19% | 68.59 | 68.84 | 35.36 | ||
| 30 | sealyp NEW | 68.00% | 69.42 | 70.15 | 35.30 | ||
| 31 | jmm483 | 66.44% | 69.64 | 70.45 | 33.70 | ||
| 32 | shsusa - 1936-present PR | 50.61% | 68.17 | 68.32 | 33.08 | ||
| 33 | Hawks7 | 58.75% | 68.60 | 68.91 | 32.82 | ||
| 34 | mikelesa | 60.87% | 69.39 | 70.12 | 32.39 | ||
| 35 | AlexB | 63.32% | 68.17 | 68.29 | 32.08 | ||
| 36 | J.D.'s 1936 to Present Proof Set | 54.52% | 69.22 | 69.77 | 30.07 | ||
| 37 | Benchan | 61.32% | 68.83 | 68.92 | 29.65 | ||
| 38 | PCGS2021 | 57.86% | 69.17 | 69.48 | 27.79 | ||
| 39 | rbroederer | 41.25% | 68.13 | 68.23 | 27.00 | ||
| 40 | Proof Set: 1936- | 53.85% | 69.56 | 70.35 | 26.27 | ||
| 41 | Rick Jung | 52.73% | 69.59 | 70.33 | 24.99 | ||
| 42 | khoward132 | 45.48% | 69.15 | 69.61 | 24.89 | ||
| 43 | BigTrapper | 49.05% | 68.77 | 69.03 | 23.59 | ||
| 44 | Wineman | 10.37% | 65.32 | 65.32 | 23.03 | ||
| 45 | Nulte1 | 40.13% | 67.49 | 67.74 | 22.81 | ||
| 46 | SGTMUS 1936-Present Proof | 47.27% | 69.08 | 69.20 | 21.71 | ||
| 47 | ACM YN | 20.62% | 66.34 | 66.34 | 21.53 | ||
| 48 | Cypress Yankee | 44.26% | 69.87 | 70.75 | 21.33 | ||
| 49 | R. Hauley Proofs | 40.02% | 69.24 | 70.04 | 21.32 | ||
| 50 | Vinny Kid | 43.03% | 68.69 | 68.81 | 20.94 | ||
| 51 | Minick's Proofs 1936-Present | 42.81% | 68.78 | 68.79 | 20.24 | ||
| 52 | The J. J. Wilson Collection | 43.48% | 69.50 | 70.00 | 20.14 | ||
| 53 | bopiy | 36.57% | 68.47 | 68.57 | 20.03 | ||
| 54 | dmrogers89 | 38.35% | 68.76 | 69.01 | 19.66 | ||
| 55 | EdwardJBoyle | 40.36% | 68.87 | 68.89 | 19.28 | ||
| 56 | BigTrapper (2) | 39.24% | 69.11 | 69.27 | 18.04 | ||
| 57 | BadgerBoyJake | 36.57% | 68.78 | 68.80 | 17.92 | ||
| 58 | Timmy31m | 33.56% | 68.70 | 68.92 | 17.90 | ||
| 59 | spprtmechanic | 33.67% | 68.64 | 68.71 | 17.80 | ||
| 60 | mhewett | 38.35% | 69.01 | 69.08 | 17.69 | ||
| 61 | jayrayballard | 36.57% | 68.95 | 69.03 | 17.58 | ||
| 62 | T.O.'s 1936-Present Proof Set | 38.46% | 69.06 | 69.12 | 17.50 | ||
| 63 | Cark's Modern Proofs | 26.87% | 67.78 | 67.92 | 16.81 | ||
| 64 | Danegeld5 | 35.90% | 69.03 | 69.17 | 16.77 | ||
| 65 | njf | 35.90% | 68.96 | 68.96 | 16.52 | ||
| 66 | pat4president1996 UPDATED | 28.43% | 68.43 | 68.49 | 16.31 | ||
| 67 | wolferdan | 35.23% | 68.95 | 68.95 | 16.12 | ||
| 68 | talk2thephin13 | 30.77% | 67.30 | 67.36 | 15.99 | ||
| 69 | BigTrapper (3) | 33.11% | 69.04 | 69.13 | 15.17 | ||
| 70 | Brown'sFamily | 18.73% | 67.60 | 67.81 | 15.12 | ||
| 71 | ApexCollecting.com | 15.16% | 67.33 | 67.33 | 15.06 | ||
| 72 | BillW804 | 26.09% | 68.85 | 69.29 | 15.00 | ||
| 73 | WestChi | 30.77% | 68.81 | 69.02 | 14.85 | ||
| 74 | A. R. S. Collection | 23.52% | 68.51 | 68.72 | 13.74 | ||
| 75 | Sparkmeister | 26.76% | 68.70 | 68.76 | 13.21 | ||
| 76 | pfboris01 | 13.27% | 67.38 | 67.54 | 12.78 | ||
| 77 | BigTrapper (4) | 27.76% | 69.08 | 69.12 | 12.48 | ||
| 78 | trossman | 23.41% | 68.49 | 68.51 | 12.42 | ||
| 79 | Time Travelers Coin Exchange | 13.15% | 67.33 | 67.34 | 12.31 | ||
| 80 | Bear Creek Collection | 20.29% | 68.58 | 68.69 | 11.56 | ||
| 81 | zorknapp | 19.40% | 67.89 | 67.96 | 11.34 | ||
| 82 | jaenfield | 23.63% | 69.42 | 69.91 | 11.27 | ||
| 83 | BigTrapper (5) | 23.86% | 69.01 | 69.02 | 10.73 | ||
| 84 | KClark | 18.62% | 68.24 | 68.29 | 10.61 | ||
| 85 | Steven f | 22.97% | 69.07 | 69.07 | 10.34 | ||
| 86 | nmrolfe | 18.06% | 68.55 | 68.67 | 09.58 | ||
| 87 | BigTrapper (7) | 18.28% | 68.72 | 68.73 | 09.05 | ||
| 88 | BigTrapper (6) | 20.18% | 68.66 | 68.67 | 09.04 | ||
| 89 | Rduffy97 | 14.49% | 67.97 | 68.02 | 08.95 | ||
| 90 | [email protected] | 17.73% | 69.66 | 70.43 | 08.87 | ||
| 91 | Pocketdiver | 18.17% | 69.04 | 69.27 | 08.72 | ||
| 92 | Cen-Cal | 16.83% | 68.56 | 68.56 | 08.58 | ||
| 93 | USMC Collection | 18.17% | 69.87 | 70.78 | 08.55 | ||
| 94 | joshuahansen38 | 17.95% | 69.15 | 69.32 | 08.18 | ||
| 95 | Henry4869 | 14.60% | 68.47 | 68.52 | 08.13 | ||
| 96 | BigTrapper (8) | 15.94% | 68.36 | 68.36 | 07.62 | ||
| 97 | Samuel David | 11.37% | 68.14 | 68.47 | 07.49 | ||
| 98 | Remmahtam | 3.57% | 65.66 | 65.66 | 07.27 | ||
| 99 | yountfan74 | 14.72% | 69.13 | 69.38 | 06.84 | ||
| 100 | Lbonser | 6.02% | 59.58 | 59.58 | 06.52 | ||
| 101 | Eastlake | 7.80% | 67.72 | 67.80 | 06.24 | ||
| 102 | CoinGuy1859 | 5.80% | 65.95 | 65.97 | 06.22 | ||
| 103 | RobertAgans NEW | 10.81% | 68.73 | 69.05 | 05.96 | ||
| 104 | C. Ervin | 9.25% | 68.07 | 68.18 | 05.69 | ||
| 105 | BigTrapper (9) | 10.93% | 68.78 | 68.78 | 05.25 | ||
| 106 | Ohio850 | 5.57% | 67.61 | 67.73 | 04.82 | ||
| 107 | [email protected] | 10.48% | 69.13 | 69.25 | 04.78 | ||
| 108 | chanceduncan | 10.37% | 69.02 | 69.02 | 04.62 | ||
| 109 | dz | 9.48% | 69.35 | 69.66 | 04.41 | ||
| 110 | RedHillzCoins | 9.25% | 69.06 | 69.16 | 04.13 | ||
| 111 | BigTrapper (10) | 8.92% | 68.05 | 68.05 | 04.11 | ||
| 112 | 7ville | 7.69% | 68.62 | 68.62 | 03.90 | ||
| 113 | meat1986 | 8.36% | 69.96 | 70.92 | 03.83 | ||
| 114 | Simpson Family 1936-Present Proof Set | 8.25% | 69.01 | 69.03 | 03.77 | ||
| 115 | Neibaur Family Collection II | 7.80% | 69.89 | 70.74 | 03.56 | ||
| 116 | VAL1632199 | 7.25% | 67.69 | 67.90 | 03.52 | ||
| 117 | Casa de Luna Collection Proof Set | 1.67% | 65.64 | 65.64 | 03.40 | ||
| 118 | BigTrapper (11) | 7.13% | 69.00 | 69.00 | 03.28 | ||
| 119 | Brodysafa 49 | 6.58% | 68.37 | 68.45 | 03.20 | ||
| 120 | RoadRunner60 | 5.46% | 68.78 | 69.11 | 03.13 | ||
| 121 | jghilino | 6.13% | 68.83 | 68.86 | 02.92 | ||
| 122 | TheArmasCollection UPDATED | 5.46% | 68.51 | 68.61 | 02.81 | ||
| 123 | BigTrapper (12) | 6.02% | 68.96 | 68.96 | 02.68 | ||
| 124 | The Gerlak Collection | 4.79% | 69.13 | 69.81 | 02.66 | ||
| 125 | LWENZEL | 5.57% | 69.98 | 70.96 | 02.60 | ||
| 126 | Snovacc | 5.24% | 69.22 | 69.33 | 02.44 | ||
| 127 | CosmoZ | 5.02% | 69.98 | 70.96 | 02.30 | ||
| 128 | The Bray Collection | 2.68% | 68.70 | 68.94 | 02.23 | ||
| 129 | The Swisher Proof Collection | 3.57% | 68.57 | 68.61 | 02.17 | ||
| 130 | Bleumorpho | 4.46% | 69.13 | 69.18 | 01.99 | ||
| 131 | www.coincollec.com | 4.24% | 69.03 | 69.05 | 01.99 | ||
| 132 | BigTrapper (17) | 3.79% | 68.91 | 68.91 | 01.69 | ||
| 133 | BigTrapper (13) | 3.68% | 69.00 | 69.00 | 01.64 | ||
| 134 | kriskallaway1 | 3.57% | 69.59 | 70.22 | 01.62 | ||
| 135 | maqz99 | 3.46% | 68.87 | 69.06 | 01.54 | ||
| 136 | mwyneski | 3.34% | 69.83 | 70.47 | 01.52 | ||
| 137 | joejosephson | 0.56% | 65.10 | 65.10 | 01.45 | ||
| 138 | Pinguecula | 3.23% | 68.93 | 68.93 | 01.44 | ||
| 139 | Owen's Collection | 2.45% | 68.31 | 68.41 | 01.43 | ||
| 140 | Sunrise | 1.11% | 66.62 | 66.62 | 01.39 | ||
| 141 | BigTrapper (19) | 3.23% | 66.59 | 66.59 | 01.39 | ||
| 142 | BigTrapper (14) | 3.01% | 69.04 | 69.04 | 01.34 | ||
| 143 | BigTrapper (15) | 2.68% | 69.00 | 69.00 | 01.19 | ||
| 144 | BigTrapper (20) | 2.68% | 68.96 | 68.96 | 01.19 | ||
| 145 | TJ | 2.34% | 68.71 | 68.79 | 01.19 | ||
| 146 | markrovelli | 2.01% | 69.22 | 69.74 | 01.15 | ||
| 147 | chookcity | 1.56% | 68.41 | 68.86 | 01.09 | ||
| 148 | BigTrapper (18) | 2.01% | 68.61 | 68.61 | 00.89 | ||
| 149 | BigTrapper (16) | 1.78% | 68.63 | 68.63 | 00.79 | ||
| 150 | Thoward91 | 1.34% | 67.88 | 68.00 | 00.78 | ||
| 151 | kj4kzt | 1.23% | 67.40 | 67.40 | 00.73 | ||
| 152 | J.Ryan | 1.45% | 69.69 | 69.77 | 00.65 | ||
| 153 | cszody | 1.34% | 68.83 | 68.83 | 00.59 | ||
| 154 | GunPlayInk | 1.23% | 69.73 | 69.73 | 00.55 | ||
| 155 | [email protected] | 0.89% | 69.50 | 70.00 | 00.50 | ||
| 156 | DREWPCGS | 0.22% | 66.40 | 66.40 | 00.48 | ||
| 157 | Jtg1990 | 0.89% | 69.25 | 69.38 | 00.40 | ||
| 158 | bsilverwood | 0.67% | 67.50 | 67.75 | 00.39 | ||
| 159 | Cdoug1963 Collections | 0.78% | 69.00 | 69.00 | 00.35 | ||
| 160 | Humble House | 0.56% | 69.50 | 70.00 | 00.30 | ||
| 161 | Alabama_Coin_Collector | 0.67% | 69.00 | 69.00 | 00.30 | ||
| 161 | [email protected] | 0.67% | 69.00 | 69.00 | 00.30 | ||
| 163 | Coolcoins22 | 0.11% | 67.00 | 67.00 | 00.24 | ||
| 164 | Rooster Country coins | 0.22% | 68.00 | 68.33 | 00.15 | ||
| 165 | ANGERY BOAR | 0.11% | 67.00 | 67.00 | 00.14 | ||
| 166 | Clive P. | 0.22% | 69.50 | 70.00 | 00.10 | ||
| 167 | auntieleelee | 0.22% | 68.50 | 68.50 | 00.10 | ||
| 168 | corky | 0.11% | 70.00 | 71.00 | 00.05 |