PCGS Auction Prices

Buffalo Nickel (1913-1938)

This site contains links to affiliate websites, and we may receive an affiliate commission for any purchases made on the affiliate website using such links.
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, MS
Title Lots Found Auction Record
1913 Type 1 MS 5604 $79,312.50
1913-D Type 1 MS 1979 $32,200.00
1913-S Type 1 MS 1786 $16,800.00
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, MS
Title Lots Found Auction Record
1913 Type 2 MS 1586 $17,037.50
1913-D Type 2 MS 1955 $143,750.00
1913-S Type 2 MS 2595 $49,938.00
1914 MS 1140 $30,550.00
1914/(3) Overdate MS 306 $63,250.00
1914-D MS 1808 $32,775.00
1914-S MS 1437 $46,000.00
1915 MS 1342 $5,640.00
1915-D/D MS 22 $4,920.00
1915-D MS 1331 $20,125.00
1915-S MS 1158 $55,812.50
1915-S/S MS 10 $1,703.75
1916 MS 1710 $19,200.00
1916 Doubled Die Obverse MS 281 $281,750.00
1916-D MS 1231 $24,675.00
1916-S MS 1016 $35,250.00
1917 MS 1026 $20,700.00
1917-D MS 1234 $20,700.00
1917-S MS 1053 $138,000.00
1918 MS 784 $55,200.00
1918-D MS 1108 $31,200.00
1918/7-D MS 1409 $350,750.00
1918-S MS 882 $125,350.00
1919 MS 1178 $19,975.00
1919-D MS 997 $19,975.00
1919-S MS 1073 $109,250.00
1920 MS 996 $12,650.00
1920-D MS 884 $138,000.00
1920-S MS 963 $44,563.00
1921 MS 1042 $30,800.00
1921-S MS 1783 $51,750.00
1923 MS 940 $18,400.00
1923-S MS 1411 $67,563.00
1924 MS 731 $25,200.00
1924-D MS 965 $44,063.00
1924-S MS 1221 $105,750.00
1925 MS 1096 $32,200.00
1925-D MS 946 $57,500.00
1925-S/S MS 9 $2,350.00
1925-S MS 1071 $87,400.00
1926 MS 1487 $16,450.00
1926-D MS 1064 $70,500.00
1926-S MS 2061 $322,000.00
1927 MS 1161 $24,000.00
1927-D/D MS 16 $335.00
1927-D MS 845 $46,000.00
1927-S MS 897 $125,350.00
1928 MS 994 $11,500.00
1928-D MS 1104 $17,250.00
1928-S MS 814 $46,000.00
1929 MS 1232 $63,250.00
1929-D MS 737 $15,275.00
1929-S MS 1236 $36,000.00
1930 MS 1709 $15,600.00
1930-S MS 1035 $30,550.00
1931-S MS 1962 $63,250.00
1934 MS 1062 $12,000.00
1934-D MS 1035 $23,500.00
1935 Doubled Die Reverse MS 349 $104,650.00
1935 MS 1501 $57,500.00
1935-D MS 1209 $34,800.00
1935-D/D MS 31 $999.00
1935-S MS 1327 $15,275.00
1936 MS 2132 $10,868.75
1936-D MS 1571 $37,375.00
1936-D 3-1/2 Legs MS 224 $20,700.00
1936-D/D MS 51 $1,783.00
1936-D/S MS 28 $5,875.00
1936-S MS 1440 $6,168.75
1936-S/S MS 87 $1,150.00
1937 MS 3301 $18,212.50
1937-D MS 2271 $35,250.00
1937-D 3 Legs MS 5717 $99,875.00
1937-S MS 2327 $29,900.00
1938-D/S Buffalo MS 2038 $25,300.00
1938-D Buffalo MS 10818 $23,575.00
1938-D/D Buffalo MS 1549 $30,550.00
Type 1, "FIVE CENTS" On Raised Ground, PR
Title Lots Found Auction Record
1913 Type 1 PR 434 $96,937.50
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, PR
Title Lots Found Auction Record
1913 Type 2 PR 438 $66,700.00
1914 PR 548 $49,450.00
1915 PR 492 $69,000.00
1916 PR 310 $43,125.00
1936 Satin PR 820 $18,800.00
1936 Brilliant PR 752 $40,250.00
1937 PR 1750 $40,250.00
Type 2, "FIVE CENTS" In Recess, SP
Title Lots Found Auction Record
1927 Special Strike SP 3 $47,150.00