PCGS Discovers Rare U.S. 1853/’2’ Eagle Among Bullion Coins In Paris

This Eagle flew far from home. A rare 1853/’2’ overdate U.S. Liberty Head $10 gold coin was discovered when it was recently submitted to the Professional Coin Grading Service (www.PCGS.com) office in Paris, France. The submitter did not know it was a rare variety Eagle and unknowingly included it with a group of “common” U.S. gold pieces.

The overdate coin is now graded PCGS Gold Shield MS62, the highest 1853/2 Eagle ever graded by the company in its 32 years of rare coin authentication, according to PCGS President Don Willis.

Discovered in a submission to the PCGS Paris, France office, this rare 1853/2 overdate $10 is graded PCGS MS62. Photo credit: Professional Coin Grading Service www.PCGS.com

“The overdate variety was part of a submission to PCGS Paris by a PCGS Authorized Dealer from Europe who submitted a large group of U.S. gold coins. When the grading room examination began, it was immediately detected as an overdate by PCGS Director of World Grading, Mike Sargent,” explained Willis.

“Every collector dreams of finding a rarity. Even though they have handled almost every known great rarity, our graders are no different. Everyone in the Grading Room in Paris was very excited to be part of this discovery,” recalled Willis. “This goes to show that there are still historic coins out there waiting to be discovered!”

Sargent said scarce date U.S. gold pieces are sometimes found in Europe, but “it is quite rare to find a Mint State example of such a rare coin with its natural surfaces still intact. Examples of pre-1860 Mint State $10 gold coins are scarce in any date or mintmark combination, and this particular rarity will surely be desired on the secondary market.”

PCGSCoinFacts.com, the internet’s most comprehensive resource for information about United States coins, points out that the 2 in the 1853 over 2 variety “is quite faint and easy to miss even on high grade specimens.” A portion of the number 2 can be seen as two lines in the lower loop of the number 3 digit in the date.

A portion of the number 2 can be seen in the lower loop of the 3 on the 1853/2 Eagle. Photo credit: Professional Coin Grading Service www.PCGS.com

“What the owner originally thought would be a half-ounce gold coin worth perhaps a little more than it’s weight in gold turns out to be a rare coin worth tens of thousands of dollars because PCGS experts recognized it as a desirable variety,” said Willis. “It shows once again that PCGS helps maximize the value of your coins while providing the greatest liquidity.”

Since its founding in 1986, PCGS experts have certified over 38 million coins with a total market value of over $33 billion. For information about PCGS products and services, including how to submit your coins for authentication and grading, visit www.PCGS.com or call PCGS Customer Service at (800) 447-8848. Information about the PCGS Paris office is available at www.PCGSEurope.com.

Take a look into the PCGS Price Guide, PCGS Population, and Auction History of the 1853/’2’ $10 at PCGS CoinFacts.

Related Articles

PCGS Paris Grades Scarce 2014 £2 Britannia And Lunar 'Mule' Varieties
The Paris Submission Center of Professional Coin Grading Service (www.PCGSEurope.com) has authenticated, graded and certified its first examples of the two recently reported varieties of British 2014 silver £2 Britannia and Year of the Horse "mule" error coins.

Incredibly Deceptive Alteration on Rare Colonial Caught by PCGS Graders
Some telltale marks began to match up, and despite looking superficially nothing like the holed piece, PCGS was able to conclude that the recently received coin was, indeed, none other than the Ted Craige specimen.

PCGS Certifies Two Highly Unusual and Rare Washington Quarter Errors
Keep in mind that while there are many two-headed or two-tailed coins in existence, nearly all are man-made “magician’s coins” made by sawing two coins in half and mating the matching parts.

New Million Dollar Coin: David Lawrence Sells 1879 Coiled Hair Stella
David Lawrence Rare Coins has brokered one of the rarest U.S. gold issues from the 19th Century. Graded by PCGS Proof 66 Cameo, DLRC placed an 1879 Coiled Hair $4 Gold Stella for just over $1,000,000.