Search articles

Coin Treasure Is Still Out There

-

Finding valuable coins in circulation is still possible. Every year there are countless reports of individuals finding a rare or valuable coin in circulation. For example, recently some 1992 Lincoln Cents with a reverse of 1993 or Close AM letters on the reverse were discovered. Those coins fetch over $1,000 each, even in circulated condition. Others have found varieties worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars each while looking through inexpensive coins at coin shows, coin shops or at websites like eBay. Take for example the 1975 No S Dime that was found in a proof set and later sold for $349,000 at auction. Overseas, other previously unknown coins have recently surfaced. Some of those coins are like time machines, as they take us hundreds or thousands of years back in history. Other rare, valuable or storied coins have been found in banks, vaults, behind walls or even under the ocean.

These are just a few of the reasons why numismatics is really fun and why it appeals to a new, large audience each and every year; just about anyone can find a valuable coin in change, or even when looking to buy inexpensive coins for their collections. However, we have to give credit where credit is due, and here knowledge is key. Knowledge was required in order for all these great coin treasures to be discovered, and knowledge will be an integral part of great coin discoveries in the future.

Some of my favorite rare coins are mule coins. A mule coin is a coin with two different designs that are typically mistakenly struck together. There is so much that takes place behind the scenes when mule coins get produced. As collectors, all we can do is wonder how these coins managed to escape the world’s most sophisticated mint, the U.S. Mint. The most famous and most valuable U.S. mule coins are unquestionably the Washington Quarter/Sacagawea Dollar Mules, of which there are about 15 known. As you will read later in this article, finding one even in very low circulated condition can yield $25,000 or more. The first example of the Washington Quarter Mule was discovered by Frank Wallis, who found an example inside a Sacagawea Dollar roll he purchased from Arkansas’ First National Bank in Trust. Later that year, the coin was auctioned off by Stacks Bowers, where it realized $29,900.

After the sale, collectors and dealers were surprised on how low of a price the coin brought at the auction. Many were expecting the coin to sell close to six figures or even more. One very plausible reason the coin sold for much less than expected is due to a controversial story that appeared in Coin World before the sale. The story reports that a coin dealer said someone had brought in about a dozen examples of the Washington Quarter/Sacagawea Mules to his coin shop. The individual who allegedly brought the coins in claimed the coins were acquired in change from a stamp vending machine at the local post office. After the story was published, many collectors, dealers and the public were concerned that many more examples would surface. This story more than likely prevented potential buyers from bidding higher, or from bidding at all. Unfortunately, the story was more than likely made up, as those examples never surfaced, and whoever bought the discovery coin ended up getting a great deal.

It has now been 17 years, and the coins still remain very rare and intriguing. This particular mule was struck by three different die pairs, meaning that tens of thousands of them were struck. However, after some of the first coins were found, the Mint issued a statement indicating they caught and destroyed most of them. Soon after the Mint made this statement, examples were still found, so it is very possible that some coins are still out there just waiting to be found in circulation.

I asked error coin expert Fred Weinberg what he would pay if someone found a real Washington Quarter/Sacagawea Dollar Mule in change today. He said he would pay anywhere from $25,000 and higher for a circulated example and $50,000 to $75,000 for a brilliant uncirculated example. Note, before you try and cash in your reward, be aware that altered examples of the coins exist. The fake examples are usually hollowed out Sacagawea Dollar coins with a Washington Quarter obverse inserted into it. The imitations are then gold-plated in order to duplicate the appearance of normal Sacagawea manganese coins. So, before you send your coin to Fred, make sure you send him images first, as many imitations are out there.

Circulation Finds Coin Collecting: Basics

Related Articles

1969 Roosevelt Dimes Shine for More Than One Reason Joshua McMorrow-Hernandez
11/10/2026
3 Not-So Common Cents for Use Your Common Sense Day Joshua McMorrow-Hernandez
11/4/2026
Getting into Gold Coins Successfully Joshua McMorrow-Hernandez
9/15/2026
Do You Have a Salmagundi Coin Collection? Joshua McMorrow-Hernandez
9/14/2026
Can You Sell Your Coins? Victor Bozarth
8/31/2026