| Survival Estimate | |
|---|---|
| All Grades | 27,500 |
| 60 or Better | 300 |
| 65 or Better | 20 |
| Numismatic Rarity | |
|---|---|
| All Grades | R-2.7 |
| 60 or Better | R-6.4 |
| 65 or Better | R-9.1 |
| Relative Rarity By Type All Specs in this Type | |
|---|---|
| All Grades | 4 / 66 TIE |
| 60 or Better | 1 / 66 |
| 65 or Better | 2 / 66 |
| Relative Rarity By Series All Specs in this Series | |
|---|---|
| All Grades | 4 / 66 TIE |
| 60 or Better | 1 / 66 |
| 65 or Better | 2 / 66 |
#1 PCGS MS66
"The Gerald Forsythe Collection" (PCGS Set Registry). |
#2 PCGS MS65+
As PCGS MS65 #44010341. Heritage Auctions, May 5, 2022, Lot 3761 - $78,000. As PCGS MS65+ #53980775. Subdued toning in champagne and rose, with flecks of aubergine and splashes of butterscotch. |
#2 PCGS MS65+
As PCGS MS65 #4477860. "The George Edward Collection," Stack's Bowers, August 2013, Lot 2258 - $108,687.50. Old Green Holder. As PCGS MS65+ #25357279. Heritage Auctions, January 2014, Lot 5273 - $105,750. As PCGS MS65+ #81921404. "The Duckor Family Collection of Liberty Walking Half Dollars," Heritage Auctions, January 4, 2018, Lot 4882 - $120,000; Dell Loy Hansen; "Julie's Walkers Collection (Hansen)" PCGS Set Registry. |
#2 PCGS MS65+
Ron Bauer. |
|
#6 PCGS MS65
"The Mark C. Chase Collection," Stack's Bowers, September 3, 2026, Lot 4052 - $109,800. Light golden hue, dappled on the reverse. |
#6 PCGS MS65
As PCGS MS65 #25554417. The Dakota Collection; Legend Numismatics to Eugene H. Gardner, October 2011; "The Eugene H. Gardner Collection of US Coins," Heritage Auctions, June 23, 2014, Lot 30582 - $88,125; "The Semper Fi #1 CAC-Approved Registry Set of Walking Liberty Half Dollars," GreatCollections, November 14, 2021, Lot 1070623 - $165,938.63. As PCGS MS65 #44604676. "The Rollo Fox #1 PCGS/CAC Registry Set of Walking Liberty Half Dollars," GreatCollections, May 29, 2022, Lot 1154099 - $165,937.50. |
|
#6 PCGS MS65
"The Riverside Collection of Walking Liberty Half Dollars," GreatCollections, November 15, 2020, Lot 896900 - $127,237,50. |
#6 PCGS MS65
"The Property of a Lady," Heritage Auctions, February 22, 2018, Lot 3940 - $90,000. |
#6 PCGS MS65
As PCGS MS65 #5599179. "The Eric Lane Collection of Walking Liberty Half Dollars," Heritage Auctions, August 12, 2015, Lot 4135 - $117,500. As PCGS MS65 #64212919. |
#6 PCGS MS65
|
#6 PCGS MS65
|
#6 PCGS MS65
|
#6 PCGS MS65
|
In 1921, the demobilization of World War I troops flooded the labor market and raised unemployment to a peak of 11.7%. This postwar recession led to a drop in demand for circulating coins and a steep decline in coin production, impacting every non-gold circulating denomination except the silver dollar. The silver dollar ended its 17-year hiatus by Congressional order to replenish the nation's silver dollar reserve following the melting and sale of hundreds of millions of ounces to Britain during World War I.
Demand for half dollars was significantly lower than the year before, with all three Mints producing only hundreds of thousands of examples, not the millions that were struck in the preceding year. No halves would be struck in 1922, and for the remainder of the decade, half dollar production would be sporadic. Given these low mintages, all three 1921-dated Walking Liberty Half Dollars are tough, but none surpass the 1921-S (#6585), the key to the series and one of the most valuable 20th-century circulating coins. The typical example is weakly struck, with faint left-hand detail and some weakness in the stars to the left of Liberty's face. Eagle leg detail is also often soft.
Condition attrition is the main reason why the 1921-S Walking Liberty Half Dollar is seen as the undisputed key to the series. Its mintage is more than double that of the 1921 (#6583) and the 1921-D (#6584), but far fewer were saved in Mint State, and Gems routinely trade for over $100,000.
Bruce Fox, in his 1993 Complete Guide to Walking Liberty Half Dollars, puts forward a claim from Anthony Swiatek that I've not read anywhere else. According to Swiatek, in the 1940s the P-Mint was considered the scarcest of the three issues, and some 1921-S halves had their mintmarks removed so that the coins could pass as P-Mints. Had any of these coins been Mint State examples, that would have been a real tragedy.
Regardless, many 1921-S Walking Liberty Half Dollars saw years of circulation, and most examples certified by PCGS grade PCGS AG3 to PCGS F15.
* * *
The 1921-S is the "key" date of the Walking Liberty half dollar series. But interestingly, it is not the rarest Walker in G or VG condition, and it is not the rarest Walker in Gem condition. The mintage of the 1921-S is a little more than double that of the 1921 and 1921-D. And indeed the 1921 and 1921-D are rarer in G and VG condition, as are the 1917-S obverse and even the 1938-D (which is rare in circulated grades, but not so rare in mint state). But apparently the 1921-S was not saved at the time of issue because when you get to grades VF20 and higher, the 1921-S becomes the rarest and most expensive Walking Liberty half dollar. And the 1921-S is by far the rarest Walker in mint state condition. It is not, however, the rarest Walker in Gem condition as the 1919-D is marginally rarer. But both the 1921-S and 1919-D are extremely rare in MS65 or better condition with just a handful of each known to exist in Gem condition.
The typical mint state 1921-S has soft frosty luster with somewhat of a satin look. That is of course unless the coin has toned, and there are probably as many toned mint state specimens as there are mostly white ones. Strike can be somewhat soft on this issue, though it is not the severe problem you see with the 1919-D and the S-Mints of the 1940s.