John H. Clapp Collection, sold intact in 1942 - Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr. Collection - Bowers & Merena 5/1996:960, $13,200 - Heritage 8/2004:5642, $17,825 - Heritage 2/2005:6156, not sold - Stack’s 1/2009:211, not sold - Stack's 7/2009:283, $21,850 - Heritage 4/2012:5058, not sold - Heritage 8/2012:5077, $19,975
In the Eliasberg catalog, this piece was attributed to the Harlan P. Smith Collection, sold by S.H. & H. Chapman in 5/1906, however, the named and price Harlan P. Smith catalog on the Newman Portal shows Lot 1023 (an Uncirculated 1844 Half Dime) going to “Earle” for $.80