1909-O $5 (Regular Strike)

The 1909-O Indian Half Eagle

For more than a decade, rumors circulated among workers and government insiders that the New Orleans Mint was on the chopping block. The year 1909 would ultimately prove to be the branch mint's final year of coin production. The New Orleans Mint, one of the three original Southern branches that opened in 1838, was the only one to resume coinage operations after the Civil War. The Georgia and North Carolina gold rushes that precipitated the opening of the Dahlonega and Charlotte Mints had long since fizzled out. Furthermore, the "O" Mint was the only Southern branch ever tasked with striking silver coinage, which it did heavily in its early days by melting down foreign silver into domestic subsidiary coins. Following lengthy post-war repairs and a three-year stint as an Assay Office, it was the legislated demand for silver that finally brought the New Orleans Mint back online as a full-scale money factory in 1879.

The New Orleans Mint served not just as a money factory, but also as a massive coin depository. Because the public had little practical need for the 1.5 million silver dollars the law required the Treasury to strike each month, the facility stored the unwanted bags inside its heavy, steel-lined vaults.

The nation’s silver bullion stockpile, purchased under the Sherman Silver Purchase Act (July 14, 1890), was finally exhausted by 1904, and the mandatory monthly production of silver dollars ended with it. This depletion, coupled with the opening of the modern Denver Mint and the emergence of new minting technologies, rendered New Orleans redundant. On December 4, 1909, newly appointed Mint Director A. Piatt Andrew issued an order instructing the New Orleans facility to distribute its available supply of 1909 coinage into 1910, forbidding the striking of any new coins once that remaining inventory ran dry. The order to resume coinage never came.

The New Orleans Mint Also Struck Gold

During this post-Civil War period, the New Orleans Mint also struck gold coins, though only sporadically and in just three denominations. The 1879-O Liberty Head (#8990) was its sole post-war $20 Double Eagle issue, with a tiny mintage of only 2,325 pieces. Half Eagles were struck over the course of just four separate years; the 1909-O (#8515) represents the only New Orleans issue featuring Bela Lyon Pratt’s innovative incuse Indian design.

Ten-dollar gold eagles were coined more frequently, though production was still interrupted by multi-year intermissions. None were struck in the famous Saint-Gaudens design; the mint's only 20th-century $10 issues were the Liberty Heads of 1901 (#8748), 1903 (#8753), 1904 (#8756), and 1906 (#8761).

Collecting the 1909-O Indian Half Eagle

For a 20th-century absolute rarity that carries a PCGS Price Guide value between $750,000 and $1,000,000 for each of the four known Gems, the 1909-O Indian Half Eagle rarely commands the mainstream respect it deserves.

In the 5th edition of 100 Greatest U.S. Coins, authors Jeff Garrett and Ron Guth rank the ubiquitous "key date" 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln Cent (BN #2426) at #27, yet the 1909-O $5 gold piece fails to make the list entirely. This oversight severely undersells the Bela Lyon Pratt series. Ultimately, a complete set can only be assembled by an advanced collector armed with patience, dauntless determination, and deep financial resources.

Strike, Luster, and Visual Characteristics

Despite the operational wind-down at the New Orleans Mint during its final year of coin production, the 1909-O possesses average-to-above average physical characteristics:

• Strike: The typical strike of a 1909-O is just a cut above average, though the "O" mintmark itself is frequently found doubled or weakly impressed.The reverse is typically sharper than the obverse.
• Coloration: Surfaces display a beautiful color palette, often ranging from a subtle greenish hue to a rich, warm orange-gold. Circulated pieces have often been cleaned and robbed of their original skin.
• Texture: Genuine Mint State examples regularly exhibit above-average luster paired with remarkably frosty, attractive surfaces.

Survival Rate

Coinage operations for the 1909-O Indian Half Eagle concluded abruptly on April 1, 1909, leaving a tiny total mintage of just 34,200 coins. The PCGS Population Report indicates that fewer than 2.5% of that original mintage is accounted for in certified holders today. Furthermore, an analysis of historical submission timelines for condition-census coins suggests that the current PCGS MS64 population may be significantly overstated due a lack of auction appearances for several examples that were graded 25-30 years ago.

Recent private dealer-to-dealer transactions reported to PCGS confirm the on-the-ground reality: this historic date is becoming increasingly difficult to source. The market is drying up rapidly, making the coin a ellusive even for collectors merely seeking a choice PCGS MS63 example.

* * *

There is one Superb Gem, the incredible Clapp-Eliasberg specimen. Gordon Wrubel and I bought this coin in the October, 1982 Eliasberg auction for $30,800. We sold it right away for a small profit. David Akers has handled this coin several times since and the price is, shall we say, somewhat higher than what Gordon and I paid in 1982!!!!!